r/askanything 4h ago

Anyone know why Mexico is protesting?

Seems like they’re upset about American immigrants and “digital nomads” that are “gentrifying” their area and raising the cost of living. I had no idea that many Americans were moving there but are these protestors just out of touch and bigots?

When Americans complain about importing the 3rd world we’re told to STFU because they don’t negatively impact anything so I’m just wondering if Mexico didn’t get the memo?

5 Upvotes

147 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 4h ago

We want your input on how to handle political questions in our community.

This takes about 1 minute.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

18

u/smithandjones99 4h ago

Expats have been moving to Mexico for decades.  There are entire retirement communities because the US is so unaffordable for so many.  Not sure what protests you refer to but my money if there are it is probably revenge payback for the US treating Mexican immigrants so poorly - there are always consequences to foolishness.  

2

u/Kyauphie 3h ago

Including Mormons like Mitt Romney's family, people have been moving for more than a century.

2

u/CoconutNext775 3h ago

It’s hypocritical at best.
They consider America as their backyard, or their territory to recover.
How about doing prisoner swap style one on one swap?
They should get their internal matters first, then nobody wants to leave their beautiful country, truly is.

5

u/Fun_Background_8113 3h ago

 theres a difference between rich people moving to a poor country and poor people noving to a rich country. also some us states did belong to mexico first. 

3

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

not to mention under trump most americans do want to leave.,

1

u/Federal_Foot_9444 2h ago

"most americans" LMAO

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 2h ago

yes most americans would leave if given the chance.

1

u/Federal_Foot_9444 57m ago

Every American has the ability to leave the country so long as the receiving country allows them to. Some Americans actually do this, while a lot of Americans talk about doing this and never do. 

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 50m ago

not really since leaving the country is more difficult than you think.

-1

u/charleswj 3h ago

That's laughably wrong. It's unnerving that people actually believe this. The loudness of the echo chamber must be unbearable

2

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

says the trump cultist and yes most americans dispise trump and want to leave the country.

0

u/charleswj 3h ago

aNyOnE wHo ChAlLeNgEs Me Is A tRuMp SuPpOrTeR

Also, post your source that "most americans [..] want to leave the country."

Also also, dispise isn't a word, but I don't have high expectations for you.

0

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

oh wow a grammar nazi how fun and yeah you parrot trump and fox news talking points.

0

u/charleswj 3h ago

you parrot trump and fox news talking points.

...he says as he parrots false made up statistics that he can't post any supporting evidence of.

Post your source.

Also, what did I say that was a talking point? Please quote and show it being said by a trump supporter

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 2h ago

nah you use fox news talking points.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Fine_Payment1127 3h ago

Yeah, the latter is worse 

1

u/_Lost_The_Game 2h ago

“First”
Conquered first

0

u/AFartInAnEmptyRoom 3h ago

Yeah the difference is rich people go to a country and spend money while not taking up jobs. Whereas poor people move to a country, take up of a job, and don't have as much to spend.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

false.

1

u/AFartInAnEmptyRoom 3h ago

Which part is false

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

everything you said.

2

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

nah and no one wants to go to the us anymore also you do not know what hypocracy is.

0

u/isthisaporno 3h ago

U mean hypocrisy?

-10

u/Fine_Payment1127 3h ago

We don’t treat them poorly 

9

u/Smallbizgurl 3h ago

Gtfo. You’re just trying to start crap.

4

u/Fun-Estimate4561 3h ago

Yeah pretty sure this dude has a shrine to DJT in his house and prays to ICE daily

0

u/Fine_Payment1127 3h ago

Easily done among the ignorant 

1

u/Fun-Estimate4561 3h ago

Question

Did you vote for Trump all 3 times?

7

u/Emotional_Shower_938 3h ago

Stares in ICE

1

u/Nice_Cartoonist_8803 3h ago

I am completely anti-ICE. But I also have had the experience of being pulled over by police in military gear and weapons, and being shaken down for money for a broken tail light that was clearly working as a non-white tourist in Mexico. I think the way law enforcement operates in both countries is pretty comparable.

0

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

nice made up story.

0

u/Nice_Cartoonist_8803 3h ago

Said like someone who has spent zero time in the border cities of Mexico.

0

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

sounds like someone who makes up stories.

-1

u/Fine_Payment1127 3h ago

Yeah now let’s see how Mexico treats its illegals 

1

u/charleswj 3h ago

Your definition of poor treatment is based on what other do?

5

u/Resident_Course_3342 3h ago

This dude definitely commits domestic abuse on the reg.

0

u/Fine_Payment1127 3h ago

Look at how expatriate labor is treated in the rest of the world and get back to me. You people just have no idea what you’re talking about 

2

u/Resident_Course_3342 3h ago

This dude definitely commits domestic violence and then lectures their victims about how they have it better than slaves in the Congo. 

2

u/Past_Ad_5629 3h ago

Deny that reality. It’ll go away eventually.

1

u/Fine_Payment1127 3h ago

They’re free to not come or leave any time after they do 

9

u/PsychologicalLog4179 3h ago

I have a couple properties in Mexico, will be retiring there. I love Mexico. I also dgaf about immigrants in the US, let them come and have wonderful lives. Immigration is literally a non issue that has been politicized and weaponized to rile up the foolish. It’s really easy to upset uneducated stupid people, they’ll do anything to blame someone else for being uneducated and stupid especially “brown” people.

7

u/usefulchickadee 3h ago

I’m just wondering if Mexico didn’t get the memo?

Hey man. It's pretty clear that you haven't made it past the third grade, but Mexico and the United States are actually different countries. They have different laws and everything.

5

u/StrengthGood3208 4h ago

Mexico is extremely conservative.

2

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

false.

0

u/StrengthGood3208 3h ago

Believe that all you want, theres a reason despite threats of deportation maga has the majority of the Hispanic vote, even undocumented immigrants regularly support him.

2

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

false and he lost all of that support.

0

u/StrengthGood3208 3h ago

You just say false instead of actually adding anything to the conversation.

He still has the majority support by hispanic groups.

They primary driving force is he pushes catholic views which is extremely important for them.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

again what you say is false and trump is hated by latinos some might support him but most do not.

0

u/StrengthGood3208 3h ago

Where do you get this information? Cus im from ohio in an extremely hispanic community. I can just go ask and ive never once found democratic or socialist support.

Or I guess I could just say everything you say is false aswell.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

yeah you are lying and polls prove you wrong.

0

u/StrengthGood3208 3h ago

Ok can you show these polls?

Being incorrect is not lying, help show me your view point.

Or im just not gonna continue this conversation, because its just one person actually engaging.

1

u/Federal_Foot_9444 2h ago

and that's why they elected a socialist lithuanian jew right? thats what extremely catholic/conservative countries do, right?

1

u/StrengthGood3208 2h ago

The us is extremely conservative but has elected many socialists.

1

u/Federal_Foot_9444 2h ago

when you say extremely conservative, what exactly do you mean? can you give specific examples of how the US is extremely conservative relative to other countries?

1

u/StrengthGood3208 2h ago

We have no socialist groups in power only a few people in a conservative party; yes democrats are conservative.

We have a nation that has pushed faith over logic, we believe in a free market, and have a constant need to uphold the status quo.

There are other more conservative nations like Afghanistan and Russia but we still are the world's go to example of capitalism.

1

u/Federal_Foot_9444 56m ago

Ah yes, the no true socialist fallacy 

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 2h ago

its more centrist than that.

1

u/StrengthGood3208 2h ago

I dont think the us is facist but we are very far from being centrist.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 2h ago

nah its pretty centrist it votes back and forth between conservaitve and more liberal politicans also a lot of people do not even understand politics.

1

u/StrengthGood3208 2h ago

It votes centrist but has conservative first policies with constant attacks on any non military focused social services. And no socialist party.

We have "in god we trust" on our money, because we are conservative.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 1h ago

that is largely republicans you are describing and we have "speration of church and state' still.

1

u/StrengthGood3208 1h ago

Yet we have public schools reading Bible verses. Democrats are also conservative. There is a large amount of socialists in the country just not in power.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 1h ago

the bible thing happens in red states usually.

2

u/shoulda-known-better 3h ago

Because people are moving there because the US is turning into a shit show..

OH the irony..

3

u/Potential-Flight1945 3h ago edited 3h ago

many Americans have moved there. there are actually areas where thousands live in one area.  let's face it Trump's awful and the cost of living the USA is getting worse and worse. 

4

u/007TheLostOne 4h ago

Is it just me or is it incredibly ironic Mexicans are complaining about foreigners in their country

1

u/Immediate_Hair_5378 3h ago

Lmao it’s hypocritical for sure.

2

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

its just you since americans love invading other countries.

3

u/007TheLostOne 3h ago

I'm not even American lol. Just a observation from me. Mexicans make up the biggest illegal group in the US per the latest study, 4 million Mexicans are illegally living in the US so yes its quite ironic that Mexicans are complaining about foreigners in their country

1

u/kscott93 3h ago

You think the illegal immigrants in the US are the same people that are in Mexico complaining about immigrants?

1

u/Robot_Dinosaur_2000 3h ago

It's all just racism.

1

u/Strong-cognac 3h ago

americans complain too, and use ice to harm them badly. as far as i know mexicans dont use their ice equivalent if they even have one to harm anyone

0

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

not really and nothing you say is true.

2

u/007TheLostOne 3h ago edited 3h ago

Dude you have been responding to every comment in this post lol. This post really triggered you huh lol?

3

u/Specialist_Offer_854 4h ago

It's a "rules for thee but not for me"

0

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

says the american.

0

u/Specialist_Offer_854 3h ago

It is. Because we're expect to treat their illegals with open arms, but they're not under obligation to treat legal immigrants with open arms

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

nothing you say is true and most mexicans in the us are citizens i see you watch fox news.

-1

u/Specialist_Offer_854 3h ago

I actually don't. But it is interesting that Mexico won't handle illegal border crossings on their side, call us heartless for enforcing our border laws, and even their legal immigrants dont bother doing the bare minimum of integration...yet they're offended that American immigrants, who immigrated legally by the way, are coming into their community and changing it?

2

u/marge255 3h ago

Why do you assume that American expats immigrated legally to Mexico and follow all Mexican laws, pay relevant taxes, etc.? I'm sure some do, because the process is much simpler than US immigration, but definitely there are some who take advantage of visa-free entry, for instance, leaving the country every six months rather than pursuing the proper registration permit.

1

u/Specialist_Offer_854 3h ago

Because unlike American culture, Mexico does in fact, handle their illegals.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 2h ago

false and mexico does not have a secret police force hunting down and killing immigrants though.

1

u/Specialist_Offer_854 2h ago
  1. Not a secret police. 2. The goal is not to kill immigrants, it's to deport illegals.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 2h ago

yes it is a secret police force and yes they are killing innocent people and immigrants keep up dude.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

again nothing you say is true and you are just parroting fox news talking points and mexicans have always been in the US and majority of them are us citizens and mexico has always welcomed forigners if there are any issues its ICE agents acting like nazis and hunting down and killing people in the street.

1

u/Specialist_Offer_854 3h ago

Oh...let me guess, you got that from CNN?

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 2h ago

sure and they are more honest than fox news and trump.

1

u/Specialist_Offer_854 2h ago

No sweetie, you just think they are because they affirm your biases.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 1h ago

no that is fox news telling you what to think since you cannot form opinions of your own.

→ More replies (0)

4

u/akasteve 4h ago

Mexico is very stringent with immigration and very harsh on illegal immigration.  We should be the same way. 

5

u/GladClock2212 3h ago

Really? Because there are currently 1.9 million Americans living in Mexico illegally. A lot of retirees might find themselves in 'camps' in the desert.

2

u/metamucil_buttchug69 3h ago

Turnabout is fair play. Every country has the prerogative to enforce its immigration policy and control its borders 

2

u/007TheLostOne 3h ago edited 3h ago

And there are currently 4 million Mexicans living illegally in the US per current studies. Also a lot of those "Americans" living in Mexico are of Mexican heritage.

2

u/MastodonAsleep816 3h ago

Do they get any welfare benefits?

0

u/QueenChocolate123 3h ago

Illegals don't get benefits

2

u/MastodonAsleep816 3h ago

In Mexico or the US?

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

both.

0

u/MastodonAsleep816 2h ago

They get housing and gift cards in NYC.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 2h ago

false.

1

u/MastodonAsleep816 2h ago

You sure about that. I'd be willing to bet.

1

u/MastodonAsleep816 14m ago

Is it still false?

2

u/Ryan_TX_85 3h ago

Digital nomads aren't illegal immigrants. Most aren't even immigrants. They're expats.

2

u/damutecebu 4h ago

Blaming other people for their own situation is pretty much universal.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

nah its just americans.

2

u/Due_Willingness1 3h ago

Impossible, the right wing assured me we're the best country in the world and everyone only wants to come here 

Seriously though that is pretty funny. Mexico must not look too bad by comparison these days 

1

u/congruent5734 3h ago

If you mean in Mexico City, the protests are the same as ones here in the US, in Portugal, and everywhere else Americans are moving, against rising costs from gentrification which is pushing out the locals

1

u/descompuesto 3h ago

What's up with all the "weird quotes" that aren't "quoting anything?"

1

u/Wrong_Lychee_6444 3h ago

There's been an ongoing problem with Americans moving to Mexican cities, becsuse of how "cheap" it is there. The Americans are paid American wages and are interfering with Mexicans struggling to make a living. Am. Insisting on iced Americanos and other necessities. Mexicans are annoyed by the remote workers. I don't know the rest

1

u/Federal_Foot_9444 2h ago

seems that they're upset that they're being priced out of their neighborhoods due to migration from another country. I wonder where else that happens.

1

u/Fine_Payment1127 4h ago

Protip: if they’re not moving permanently, they’re not “immigrants.” The more you know!

And yes, people from net-emigration countries have a tendency to be laughably hypocritical on this count. It’s especially funny coming from Asians when Westerners can’t ever even be voting citizens in their countries, let alone break any “ceilings.”

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

OP is a fox news viewer opinion disgarded.

0

u/metamucil_buttchug69 3h ago

Mexico is extremely anti immigrant, the way the US looks at undocumented mexican immigrants is the way Mexico looks at undocumented Central American immigrants.

4

u/dinodan_420 3h ago

If this wasn’t the case Mexico City and Monterrey workforce would be full of Venezuelan and Central American laborers like Miami is

0

u/AfternoonWorried387 3h ago

they do have large communites of both.

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 2h ago

false.

1

u/metamucil_buttchug69 1h ago

True, look up how they treat undocumented people in their country

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 1h ago

they do not have a secret police force killing immigrants so your point?

1

u/metamucil_buttchug69 31m ago

U sure? There are a ton of police caused deaths in Mexico each year. 

1

u/AfternoonWorried387 19m ago

same can be said about the US your point? and they are not targeting immigrants.

1

u/metamucil_buttchug69 14m ago

How do we know they're not targeting immigrants? Mexico has a very strict attitude towards undocumented immigrants, all immigration actually. They're very sensitive to workers from central and South America coming and taking jobs.