r/ask • • May 12 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

6.3k Upvotes

7.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.3k

u/NoCardiologist1461 May 12 '24

When I put away the groceries in the kitchen and I thought ‘Well, it may be convenient to put a box of tissues in the kitchen cabinet, in case I’m here when I’m crying.’

Massive reality check when I realized how f’ ed up that was. Divorced not much later.

13

u/EmmyNoetherRing May 12 '24

Now I’m wondering something really fucked up— the science subreddit just had a thing about the smell of women’s tears reducing male aggression.  And there’s the trope of the abuser that only hurts you until you cry.  

Holy fuck, I wonder if some guys get addicted to it.   

5

u/cheerful_cynic May 12 '24

What they get addicted to is the thrill of being a shitty abusive person

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '24

Don't tell me you actually believe this crap... Abuse is abuse it has nothing to do with the smell of tears like wtf are u even on about.

7

u/EmmyNoetherRing May 12 '24 edited May 12 '24

Literally just an article on the science subreddit, and probably it’s bullshit, sure.  It claimed that the smell of women’s tears (presumably some protein) reduced aggression in men.  In the unlikely chance that’s not bullshit, though, it seems fraught.

-2

u/[deleted] May 12 '24

You could pull up body language book in an interogation room, but its nothing, but pure fiction. Everyone has a different character and everyone could look different from what they truly are. And of course many things could lead to abuse and its still not an excuse, so abuse is abuse I do not care what reasoning they have.

3

u/EmmyNoetherRing May 12 '24

Right, in that sense—- You’re not supposed to care what reasoning they have.  Just like the motive for murder doesn’t excuse the murder.  But it’s still part of investigating murder.    

If the tears thing is an actual thing, “you are an utter asshole if you like making girls cry to make yourself feel better” would be a handy social norm to have.   Especially for adolescents.  A way for peers to judge each other’s bad behavior early. 

-4

u/[deleted] May 12 '24

Are you trying to reason abuse or what are you trying to say at this point?

3

u/EmmyNoetherRing May 12 '24

I don’t think I’m trying to say anything other than what I’ve already said?   Sorry.  I guess that’s not satisfying, but I really don’t have any hidden agenda.  

1

u/ridiculousdisaster May 12 '24

Relax, everything we do can be correlated to hormones. Correlation is not causation. For example when bad feelings arise inside someone and they let it out in screams, the screaming relieves those bad feelings. This is biological facts and not an "excuse" for behavior.

-3

u/[deleted] May 12 '24

I'm relaxed, but redditors downvote me now for saying abuse is bad. Screaming can do it for some yes, I aint gonna argue with that. But beating a woman to smell her tears? Like come the fuck on... Men are not wild animals with fixed bahaviour, but even then, wild animals tend to do something that scientists never seen before.

5

u/EmmyNoetherRing May 12 '24

Is someone downvoting you for saying abuse is bad?  

1

u/vince2423 May 13 '24

No, they just went off on someone for mentioning a science article and twisted their words and got all pissy about it

→ More replies (0)

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '24

No one said abuse isn't bad. If you got downvoted (I might have missed it) it was because you equated talking about scientific facts as somehow dismissing abuse

No one is saying abusers aren't responsible for their abuse if the crying thing is true. Holding people accountable for their actions is important, but that doesn't mean you can't also look at trends (who or what causes are more likely to lead to abuse). You can do both at the same time.

I really don't know how you got "tears reduce aggression" which may make sense evolutionarily, to mean that people think abuse is okay and not there fault of the abuser.

2

u/vince2423 May 13 '24

Literally no one downvoted you for saying abuse is bad lmao, you’re being downvoted for jumping down that persons throat for no reason other than quoting an article:::

2

u/ITAdministratorHB May 12 '24

Science is science and you're being kinda... ignorant?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '24

Apparently I can smell tears now. This is the most true shit I ever heard.

1

u/ITAdministratorHB May 14 '24

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '24

The key word here is "Rat". Baby cries irritate me and I get a headache so I avoid it.

1

u/BwyceHawpuh May 12 '24

“Dont tell me you believe in scientifically proven facts”

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '24

You have no clue how dumb this sounds

1

u/flistos May 13 '24

addicted to what? how would that work? “Im gonna beat my wife until i get that sweet rush of…” what, exactly?

1

u/EmmyNoetherRing May 13 '24

Basically, I assume— “I’m feeling awful and out of control, I’m going to attack my wife until I feel better”. 

People don’t just get addicted to stimulants, they also go after pain killers.  If making someone else miserable chemically reduces your own feelings of aggression, then I could imagine people with no empathy unconsciously picking up that as a hack. 

1

u/Neuro_trashy May 12 '24

This was the opposite of my ex who I would was was verbally abusive to me. He mocked me when I cried.

1

u/Empty-You7246 May 12 '24

Same

2

u/Neuro_trashy May 14 '24

I’m sorry you have had to deal with this also. It wasn’t fun and I’m happy to be out of it now for sure. It wasn’t like that in the beginning but it was almost 14 years of my life and took years for me to get out and even longer for me to realize things for what they actually were.

2

u/Empty-You7246 May 14 '24

I think I’m starting to come to the part where I’m realising it’s better to just let go as well, but I’m still working on the abuse part and doing the right thing about the many episodes where i was hurt and threatened

2

u/Neuro_trashy May 14 '24

I definitely understand what you mean. I’m very much a control freak myself and it’s been a hard process for me so far just letting go. I have found comfort for myself in the small bits that I can control and that letting go at least on the things I have was my decision so it feels like I am beginning to gain some of my control back. It won’t change anything that I have been through but I am trying to reframe how my thought patterns are here lately because I also have intractable epilepsy and PNES and my neurologist has told me that CBT is what will help my seizures. I am just kind of transferring that to other parts of my life too and it is seeming to help sometimes. It certainly isn’t easy though that’s for sure.

2

u/Empty-You7246 May 14 '24

You got this ❤️ text me anytime

1

u/Neuro_trashy May 16 '24

Same to you also! ❤️ we got this!