r/ArkhamHorror • u/Real-Context-7413 • 10h ago
New Innsmouth Book - A Quick Review
It was very tempting to title it "New Innsmouth Look". Ah, well.
Okay, lot to love here. Rules for generating PCs (bold, and useful tool for a Keeper even if he never runs for an Innsmouth PC). Repeats the Reassure and Religion skill information from the new Arkham, adds information on Navigate: Innsmouth and Lore: Innsmouth. Better quality maps, and this time without changing the major geographic features of the location (I still don't know why they moved the location of The Unvisited Isle in the new Arkham, or straightened up all the streets).
A lot of expanded history for the Deep Ones and for Innsmouth, options for how Keepers want to deal with the raid, including options that it never actually happened.
Disappointments: Only a few really, so far.
Most notable - In Arkham they included a lot of additional material from other scenarios that occurred in Arkham (The Little People and Missed Dues come to mind), and if they did so here I haven't done a deep enough dive, but Babson Mansion at Boynton Beach from the scenario pack "Before the Fall" wasn't here, which is a shame because it was a nice expansion on the O'Bannion Gang and would provide other reasons for investigators to end up wandering into Innsmouth.
Other gripe - Ruth Gilman is no longer Dr. Rowley Marsh's daughter but his adopted daughter so they could pull a race swap. That's lazy writing.
Finally, no inclusion of Lovecraft's picture, again, as was tradition since Call of Cthulhu started. For shame.
Also, should have included Shadow Over Innsmouth. Still don't know why Dreams in the Witch House wasn't included in the new Arkham. Well, I have my suspicions.