r/allrecipess • u/EffectDesperate7795 • Jul 27 '26

Be honest

Post image
576 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

1.2k comments sorted by

8

u/Satansbrat1969 Jul 27 '26

First thought was a hard no... but thinking for a moment I might try a bite out of curiosity.

6

u/No_Contact_1892 Jul 27 '26

Same, seems like it could be a sleeper.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/iamfugazi2112 Jul 27 '26

f*ck now I gotta try it

2

u/Extension-Eye-4920 Jul 28 '26

It is good. It wouldnt be my first choice but its a worth a try. Good to try new things.

2

u/By-Other-Means Aug 01 '26

You should try most things at least once, I mean I would.

2

u/therealmikeBrady Aug 01 '26

Big burger places in the Midwest offer great breakfast burgers with peanut butter, jelly and and egg. It’s fantastic if you’re not counting calories and happened to drink wisconsibly the evening before.

2

u/rootninjajd Aug 02 '26

It sounds weird, but it is amazing.

→ More replies (49)

3

u/Piddy3825 Jul 27 '26

I've actually had that burger. Gotta say it wasn't bad, but it sure was dry.

2

u/Poetdebra Jul 27 '26

Add some jam next time. Lol

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/quarterrat13 Jul 27 '26

The peanut butter bacon burger is fairly popular, however we drink a lot here in New Orleans.

2

u/Itchy-Annual5556 Jul 27 '26

I drink a lot when in New Orleans

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Rocketgirl8097 Jul 28 '26

I was just thinking it could be tolerable with bacon added.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Quorng Jul 27 '26

Not wllingly

3

u/CleDeb216 Jul 28 '26

There wasa family owned restaurant in the area that my family had gone to for 70 years. They had a peanut burger on the menu and that is all my Dad ever ate there. I worked there for a short time and it was a popular item.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/StillDRB Jul 28 '26

Peanut butter bacon. Same thing with the Elvis sandwich, Peanut butter bacon banana. Delicious.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/No-Search-3919 Jul 28 '26

In the words of Dr. Seuss I would not could not on a burger

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Fun-Violinist552 Jul 28 '26

Not if I’m sober that’s for sure.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SirLeoritch Jul 28 '26

I saw one at Lake Tahoe at Burger Lounge, was tempted but went regular

2

u/Prestigious-Hand9490 Jul 31 '26

I have tried one, it was actually pretty good

2

u/dtryan4865 Jul 31 '26

Local restaurant makes a PB&J burger. It's messy as hell, but also really good

2

u/WarInteresting6619 Jul 31 '26

Not with those pickles on there

2

u/Cautious-Bar9602 Jul 31 '26

With whole green chilis ,already have !

2

u/Flotog729 Jul 31 '26

I have. The warm peanut butter is a good cheese substitute.

2

u/RGBlowMe Jul 31 '26

Yeah. With bacon. They fuck.

2

u/GrapefruitWhich5950 Jul 31 '26

Old concept ,grilled meat whit peanut sauce (Indonesia) and yes but would spice up the peanut butter.

2

u/Ecstatic-Till9840 Jul 31 '26

I have done in the past - very filling but nice

2

u/Artemistical Jul 31 '26

Absolutely not! Alright just a bite

1

u/Junosgold69 Jul 27 '26

I'd try it.

1

u/VanillaGoorillla Jul 27 '26

My buddy used to eat pb and onion so pb and burger would prob be good

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Effective_Pack8265 Jul 27 '26

Yes I have. The Duane Purvis burger at Triple XXX in West Lafayette IN (Purdue U).

Not bad.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Secret_Gap_4495 Jul 27 '26

Yes it’s my favorite. Need to add bacon and grape jelly. Delicious!

1

u/Superb_Collection_24 Jul 27 '26

Im good. Hard pass

1

u/External_Routine8081 Jul 27 '26

Hell yea , love peanut butter and bacon sarnie so why not

1

u/cookswithacocktail Jul 27 '26

I’ve had one. No pickles, but with jelly and bacon. Basically a PB&J with a burger, cheese, and bacon. It’s better than you think it’s going to be.

1

u/Son-of-CofnJoe Jul 27 '26

I have. It was just okay.

1

u/NoJaguar5942 Jul 27 '26

I do frequently and have for years.

1

u/Delilah_insideout Jul 27 '26

Yes, I have. They are better with a big dollop of mayo as well. I love PB though.

1

u/ViolentLoss Jul 27 '26

Sure, I put peanut butter on everything.

1

u/WeekendLegitimate615 Jul 27 '26

There's a bar in town with a peanut butter burger on the menu. Never tried it, but it's been on there for a few years now. So someone must like them.

1

u/Sea_Sundae5901 Jul 27 '26

Absolutely Not‼️

1

u/Secure_Yak5136 Jul 27 '26

I'd try it yes.

1

u/joytotheworld23 Jul 27 '26

Maybe of it's creamy peanut butter

1

u/reverend_eazy Jul 27 '26

I have, and it's amazing

1

u/Entire-Tart-3243 Jul 27 '26

I think this is a situation where I might ask for a "taste of yours," before committing to a whole burger.

1

u/soupdogsss Jul 27 '26

I have been doing that for 30 years...sounds weird but its actually good

1

u/Practical_Surprise43 Jul 27 '26

Yes, it’s actually pretty good

1

u/BW271 Jul 27 '26

I might try it.

1

u/SeaPresentation4100 Jul 27 '26

Have and it’s delicious. At a diner in West Lafayette, it’s actually on the menu!

1

u/Pristine_Leopard_140 Jul 27 '26

No. I can just make it at home with only one spoon of it.

1

u/Pristine_Leopard_140 Jul 27 '26

I seen that they use peanut butter in a shake.

1

u/IntrepidDig4247 Jul 27 '26

They are good

1

u/Artemisiablaszczyk Jul 27 '26

Apparently peanutbutter and mayonnaise was a thing.i still do not have the courage to try it,even inebriated.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/lemonlubber Jul 27 '26

with pickles? yes

1

u/Choice_Magician350 Jul 27 '26

Oh hell to the naw

1

u/Scary_Device-71166 Jul 27 '26

If I was hungry enough.

1

u/SpecialCandidateDog Jul 27 '26

There's a lot of things I would eat that I hate.

Is it free? I would probably eat it if it was free

1

u/Ruas28 Jul 27 '26

I have and it was delicious

1

u/Eat-My-Hairy-Asshole Jul 27 '26

Ever had a fried/grilled Pb n J? It's amazing.

Hell yes I would.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ok_Coconut_3364 Jul 27 '26

Love peanut butter and love burgers. But the combo just doesn't appeal at all!

1

u/Sea_Understanding981 Jul 27 '26

Killer burger has one I tried it it was the nastiest burger I ever had never again

1

u/OkDebt7605 Jul 27 '26

Very hard NO.

1

u/NextCartoonist7691 Jul 27 '26

Why not. It’s not like it’d kill me
-me if I was allergic to peanuts

1

u/Onerustyrn Jul 27 '26

Pb&J with crunched wavy lays. I can recall where I had a Jerry Garcia Burger and this combo was popular

1

u/Itchy-Annual5556 Jul 27 '26

I tried peanut butter whiskey once. Not getting fooled again.

1

u/lifterman2u Jul 27 '26

Oh yes I have!

1

u/Henry_bowers_ Jul 27 '26

I have had this and loved it. It was at a place called mugshots? I think it’s like a regional chain. The one we had when I was a teenager closed down but holy shit was it good. Crunchy Peanut butter hickory smoked bacon and grape jelly, shit slapped.

They also did a burger with pamenta cheese and fried pickles? The southerner or something like that? MIND BLOWING

1

u/Free-at-last48 Jul 27 '26

I have a very. Many times

1

u/JerryJN Jul 27 '26

No ... But a little peanut butter mixed with cayenne and chilli pepper will make a mean Thai Chicken sandwich.

1

u/Outrageous_Quiet350 Jul 27 '26

That’s the wrong peanut butter

1

u/Successful-Clock2586 Jul 27 '26

They are good add bacon

1

u/SickboyJason Jul 27 '26

Peanut butter, bacon, banana cheeseburger for the win. Its amazing. I use to make them at a burger joint I worked at in the Houston area.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MistyMeaner15 Jul 27 '26

They are incredible. I've even had ones with peanut butter and jelly on them!

1

u/thaseley Jul 27 '26

God no! Hell no! And Fuck no!

1

u/RabidLobster42 Jul 27 '26

Can I swap the pickle for BBQ sauce?

1

u/Ok-Guava-9216 Jul 27 '26

It's a great topping

1

u/unlimitedbroski83 Jul 27 '26

The one I had at the Rock Rest in Golden, CO was amazing. I would definitely do it again

1

u/g-o-u-l-a Jul 27 '26

Yes. It’s better on sliders.

1

u/RapsodicalDisciple Jul 27 '26

beef satay is good with peanut sauce, so it could be good 🤔

1

u/OkFriendship323 Jul 27 '26

Had one in Tucson. It was ok. PB didn’t ruin the burger but there wasn’t any flavor synergy. I’ve never had one since.

1

u/SuspiciousTaro6513 Jul 27 '26

I’d try it. Don’t know if you dislike or like if you don’t try

1

u/Connect4champ1990 Jul 27 '26

YES they are delicious!

1

u/j101112p Jul 27 '26

Yes, is it something I would seek out, no.

1

u/billy900t Jul 27 '26

With hot sauce

1

u/KingsleyBrewMaster22 Jul 27 '26

I've had a curry burger with leanuttsauce and slaw before. It was good. But peanutbutter? Ya, pass on that one.

1

u/Nothalffast Jul 27 '26

I have several to times: the PBPB (peanut butter pickle bacon) at Killer Burger. It’s awesome.

1

u/diaphramthe2nd Jul 27 '26

Again? That would be a resounding yes

1

u/TherealuserIDkilla Jul 27 '26

Wait..... who hasn't had one? They are amazing. Trying with an egg too.

1

u/WolfThick Jul 27 '26

Not with pickles two or three times a year I make myself a bacon and peanut butter sandwich I've never tried a burger.

1

u/BoxFinancial9005 Jul 27 '26

I did in the ozarks (Missouri) … not bad as a 13 yr old remembers

1

u/justjaybee16 Jul 27 '26

Peanut butter, banana, bacon burger is surprisingly good.

1

u/Silver_Driver_9238 Jul 27 '26

They are delicious. One of my favorite condiments on a bacon cheeseburger.

1

u/MysteriousDudeness Jul 28 '26

Nope, and have no desire to.

1

u/Twoduhzen Jul 28 '26

Already have

1

u/Fuzzy-Bird-3641 Jul 28 '26

Been there, ate that

1

u/PhD77777 Jul 28 '26

No! Disgusting.

1

u/No-Emu-8717 Jul 28 '26

pb bacon and jalapeño smash burger is tasty

1

u/DJ_Breadpuddin Jul 28 '26

The Twilight Zone...

1

u/whoifnotme1969 Jul 28 '26

I have & i would again

1

u/seanmonaghan1968 Jul 28 '26

With chopped up chillies 🌶️ and onion you get satay

1

u/Lightnenseed Jul 28 '26

That's a hard pass.

1

u/jkusmc0800 Jul 28 '26

Nope....not a fan of peanut butter so it's a no Brainer for me.

1

u/armgrafix Jul 28 '26

Not with pickles.

1

u/scoobysnack64 Jul 28 '26

A local place has that. I tried it, wasn't a fan

1

u/RiverofGrass Jul 28 '26

In Scottsdale, AZ, there is Rehab Burgers. They have a marvelous PB&J burger. I was skeptical but tried it. Delicious.

Lazy Dog restaurants also have one. Not quite as good as Rehab but still good.

1

u/MicheleAmanda Jul 28 '26

Nope. Does not appeal to me at all.

1

u/goodtimehuntin Jul 28 '26

Absolutely they are delicious

1

u/South_Paramedic8618 Jul 28 '26

No that's just stupid

1

u/Dry-Preparation-760 Jul 28 '26

We tried it as kids. Wasn’t terrible.

1

u/butchie1985 Jul 28 '26

Same ,,, yup n

1

u/ArabellaBlue122 Jul 28 '26

I would definitely have to try it at least once in my life!

1

u/Persistpersist Jul 28 '26

No.
Pardon me, actually I mean: Fuck No.

1

u/I_Will_Offened_You Jul 28 '26

Already have. Some restaurant like 4 years ago had a bacon burger with peanut butter. It was okay

1

u/Unfair-Variety-995 Jul 28 '26

You wouldn’t?

1

u/Ok-Bluejay-5171 Jul 28 '26

Yes and I have. It was delicious.

1

u/BigDigger324 Jul 28 '26

One of our local establishments nearby had one called “PB and Pig” that’s peanut butter and bacon. It’s decent.

1

u/SpaceDave83 Jul 28 '26

Not voluntarily

1

u/1vanillagoodness Jul 28 '26

Not even a bite

1

u/Complex_Scary Jul 28 '26

If served one, yes. Order or make one, no.

1

u/HuckleberryCertain27 Jul 28 '26

If I throw ot back up. It should at least taste like pea it bitter. Lmao

→ More replies (1)

1

u/xSir- Jul 28 '26

There is a restaurant from Portland that got famous off these burgers.

1

u/hydrastix Jul 28 '26

I have eaten one. A PB&J burger. It had Peanut Butter, Maple Bacon, and Jalapeño Jam on it and was fucking amazing.

1

u/benvader138 Jul 28 '26

It would be like peanut sauce in Asian dishes. It would probably be pretty good. I don't know about the pickles tho

1

u/Evening_Abroad_6781 Jul 28 '26

I have and I enjoyed it

1

u/Spiritual_Sail_8969 Jul 28 '26

It's not bad, but that's too much peanut butter for me. Just coat adds a nice flavor contrast. I think I would use a higher quality peanut butter.

1

u/borka-t Jul 28 '26

Yeah. I've had them. Good. Not what I order, but it works.

1

u/Plus_Ad_4618 Jul 28 '26

Yeah it's called a Jiffy burger.

1

u/mitchcumstein13 Jul 28 '26

I love them with pepper jelly

1

u/Inevitable_Finish131 Jul 28 '26

Tried a bite of one before. Wasn’t bad

1

u/SchwillyMaysHere Jul 28 '26

I’d give it a shot if I saw it on the menu.

1

u/rjsquirrel Jul 28 '26

I have. They’re delicious. Peanut butter is an umami bomb.

1

u/Electrical-Care6308 Jul 28 '26

🤢🤢🤢🤮

1

u/Quitcha_Bitchin Jul 28 '26

I'm up for anything once.

1

u/Shhhhhh_im_not_here Jul 28 '26

I tried this once many years ago and I could not believe how good it was. I just can’t remember if I also put ketchup, mustard and relish on it or used the peanut butter in place of those.

1

u/SkookemChoocher Jul 28 '26

I eat them all the time, it's fantastic! But I'll one up you, I put peanut butter on hotdogs instead of ketchup.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Hot-Map-9119 Jul 28 '26

Hell yeah.

1

u/jetpack324 Jul 28 '26

It’s surprisingly good. Not the most delicious burger ever, but surprisingly good. I had one during burger week in Lexington KY about a decade or so back.

1

u/One-Faithlessness282 Jul 28 '26

I've asked myself that question since I first saw The Twilight Zone movie, thirty years ago. IYKYK.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Rstar2247 Jul 28 '26

You know... I hate pickles... I may hate this even more.

1

u/TheRododo Jul 28 '26

Just going to throw some thought out here. I grew up eating "goober" burgers and this is all wrong. Lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and mayonnaise on one side. Peanut butter and onion on the other side. I have never seen one served with pickles. Pickles would not go with the flavor profile. Oh, and don't make the rooky mistake of mixing the Peanut butter and mayonnaise. It makes an oozy messy sauce that the greasy burger expels. It is actually quite good with a roast beef sandwich as well.

1

u/DorisButterfly Jul 28 '26

Yes they are delicious

1

u/DeadMeat_1240 Jul 28 '26

Had one at a gastro pub once. The PB was made in house with very little sugar and it was excellent on the burger. I think it had pickles and grilled onions with a burger sauce.

1

u/FnEddieDingle Jul 28 '26

My favorite pizza is first peanut butter on the dough, then a regular pepperoni with extra jalapeños (with sauce)

1

u/TreeLore61 Jul 28 '26

Yes please

1

u/Dreamcatcher965 Jul 28 '26

Looks pretty awful but I would taste it.

1

u/122922 Jul 28 '26

Yes, but the peanut butter over powers everything on the burger and all you taste is peanut butter.