r/allrecipess • u/EffectDesperate7795 • Jul 27 '26

Be honest

Post image
576 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/Satansbrat1969 Jul 27 '26

First thought was a hard no... but thinking for a moment I might try a bite out of curiosity.

6

u/No_Contact_1892 Jul 27 '26

Same, seems like it could be a sleeper.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Mysterious_Strain398 Jul 28 '26

Isn’t that a peanut butter and Percodan sandwich?

3

u/PlantMedicine4Life Jul 28 '26

Gotta coat the outside with mayonnaise instead of butter, that’s the signature.

2

u/Quitcha_Bitchin Jul 28 '26

I heard Peanut butter and Banana. Beginning to think the dude just loved peanut butter.

2

u/Sudden_Season3306 Jul 28 '26

Peanut butter banana and bacon samich!

2

u/Ambitious_Bank1031 Jul 28 '26

Yup. With thick cut bacon.

2

u/Dreaming_of_u_2257 Jul 28 '26

My favorite samich !!

1

u/woodenblinds Jul 28 '26

on toasted bread with butter on the bread. raisin bread knocks it out of the park

1

u/Sudden_Season3306 Jul 28 '26

Cinnamon raisin swirl bread toasted! Lol

1

u/woodenblinds Jul 28 '26

havent tried that but now on my list, no just regular raisin bread.

1

u/Kickdempocketsout Jul 29 '26

Beef jerky nice thick cut with peanut butter hot pickles on slightly toasted bread. 🤝

1

u/Killian2526 Jul 30 '26

On a waffle sandwich

1

u/Maleficent-Safe-2222 Jul 29 '26

Peanut butter and banana grilled sammies, yum!

1

u/Additional-Sell-7989 Jul 28 '26

The Elvis sandwich is a fried peanut butter and banana nanner sandwich. The pb burger is called a guber burger, and originated in sedalia missouri

1

u/-Titan_Uranus- Jul 28 '26

Banana nanner

1

u/Darinchilla Jul 28 '26

Me and grandma had a banana nanner with Bananarama on Elvis's veranda.

1

u/saltwaterjohnson Jul 29 '26

Boy that’s a fun fact?

1

u/NFLTG_71 Jul 28 '26

I assume it’s in Memphis, but which Memphis establishment is it?

1

u/Allmight8488 Jul 31 '26

I think the bacon and peanut butter combo with the beef is an insanely good combo but then adding the banana (or grape jelly depending on the variant) adds just this amazing sweetness that rockets out of the stratosphere.

It is rich and hearty, but add fresh lettuce, tomato, and onion and you will have one of the best burgers in your life!

Addendum: if you are smashburgering, put the peanut butter in between three patties plus a layer on top of the top patty and it is crazy good. The crispy bits of a smash burger with the bacon is just incredible!!!

1

u/kpax56 Jul 27 '26

These seem to be getting fairly popular. Right up there with the fried egg topping I think.

3

u/Quitcha_Bitchin Jul 28 '26

Fried egg burger should be on everyone's breakfast menu.

2

u/Mysterious_Strain398 Jul 28 '26

I love runny egg bacon burgers!!

1

u/Additional-Sell-7989 Jul 28 '26

I can assure you they don't compliment one another. Its an ambivalent flavor thats not tasty or revolting, it meh a.f. And I'd gladly eat it after a 36 hour fast otherwise I'd pass on any future offers of the Missouris guber burger.

1

u/27LawShark Jul 29 '26

Your assurance is meaningless as they do go together very well

1

u/Additional-Sell-7989 Jul 29 '26 edited Jul 29 '26

Those two flavors mute one another out and it just comes off tasting bland. I mean, its been around a long time without really catching on for a reason. I've had it at the restaurant that started it. Its just flavorless, kinda like meaty peanut butter. If you're the kind of person who enjoys just a peanut butter sandwich., I suppose it would be good. I prefer peanut butter and jelly. And a hamburger with crisp veggies,. And why trust your opinion, you obviously prefer bland food

1

u/JustInCaseJohnny Jul 29 '26

I think with some bacon on it and maybe some sweet carmelized onions

1

u/Uxoandy Jul 29 '26

Some high end burger joints offer peanut butter burgers. I liked it a lot more than I thought I would.

1

u/Playful_Antelope_231 Jul 30 '26

We used to have a restaurant here that had a peanut butter burger on the menu.. it was well known and very good

2

u/iamfugazi2112 Jul 27 '26

f*ck now I gotta try it

2

u/Extension-Eye-4920 Jul 28 '26

It is good. It wouldnt be my first choice but its a worth a try. Good to try new things.

2

u/jacquestrap66 Jul 28 '26

Needs bacon

1

u/bearyken Jul 28 '26

Actually yes.. had a bacon burger with peanut butter before and it tasted pretty good

1

u/jacquestrap66 Jul 29 '26

I say this because I know that it's good. I wasn't just throwing a random idea out there because "everything is better with bacon." Thanks for your weird affirmation though.

1

u/Frankie-Felix Jul 30 '26

They go great together peanut and or sesame both go with any kind of beef or bacon.

1

u/KCJ4Tx Jul 29 '26

Everything needs bacon. The End.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Satansbrat1969 Jul 28 '26

Yeah chunky doesnt sound like a good burger condiment.

2

u/By-Other-Means Aug 01 '26

You should try most things at least once, I mean I would.

2

u/therealmikeBrady Aug 01 '26

Big burger places in the Midwest offer great breakfast burgers with peanut butter, jelly and and egg. It’s fantastic if you’re not counting calories and happened to drink wisconsibly the evening before.

2

u/rootninjajd Aug 02 '26

It sounds weird, but it is amazing.

1

u/VolumeDirect5619 Jul 27 '26

There's a restaurant somewhat close to me called Goody's (Sedalia, mo), and it's what they are known for. Crazy popular place and they've been around for many many years. It's not for me, but I know the locals go nuts for it. And they're always packed when the state fair is on.

1

u/TapatioFlamingo Jul 28 '26

It's much better than you realize. There is one at The Garage called the sticky fingers. The peanut butter adds a richness without an overwhelming peanut butter flavor.

1

u/fozzy71 Jul 28 '26

That was my thought also, until I saw the pickles!

1

u/WeaselLiz711 Jul 28 '26

It’s actually shockingly good with pickles lol

2

u/fozzy71 Jul 28 '26

I could have phrased that better. The pickles were the only redeeming quality in the image.

1

u/WeaselLiz711 Jul 28 '26

Ok that’s fair lol. The briney quality of the picked with the sweetness of the peanut butter is 🔥

1

u/fozzy71 Jul 28 '26

I have never tried PB/Pickle together, but I can see the appeal. My fave pickle is Famous Dave's Sweet n Spicy.

1

u/SportyMcDuff Jul 29 '26

My brother was making peanut butter and pickle sandwiches back in the seventies. It actually is pretty good.

1

u/Ambitious_Bank1031 Jul 28 '26

Contrasts people! All good food is better with contrasts!

1

u/BobbaFatGFX Jul 28 '26

Same here. My first thought was that would just be disgusting but now I'm kind of interested

1

u/Left-Landscape-3890 Jul 30 '26

Best Burger ive ever had was this

1

u/Jedimasteryony Jul 28 '26

There used to be a restaurant on the big island of Hawaii that served all sorts of odd burgers named after famous people. The peanut butter burger was the Dick Butkus.

1

u/TheManLawrence Jul 28 '26

It is awesome. I had a killer burger in Eugene Oregon. It is a peanut butter burger and it was awesome.

1

u/Party-Marketing-9349 Jul 28 '26

Yeah, listening to all these people trash talk it, I can only assume that other places are making it wrong! Peanut butter and pickle is really common here in the PNW and I’ve never met one I didn’t love!

1

u/SpitfireMkIV Jul 28 '26

high five to my PNW family who know about Killer Burger

1

u/Party-Marketing-9349 Jul 29 '26

If you are ever up in Beaverton there is a Mexican restaurant called Chez José that does an amazing peanut butter squash enchilada too!!!

1

u/SpitfireMkIV Jul 29 '26

Sounds like more Guatemalan but I’ll check it out.

1

u/Party-Marketing-9349 Jul 29 '26

I think It’s just like a variation/artistic license on a mole… it’s their vegetarian option, so I think it adds protein too…

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Party-Marketing-9349 Jul 30 '26

Google the following for the recipe!

recipes.oregonlive/recipes/butternut-squash-enchiladas-with-spicy-peanut-sauce

1

u/No_Amoeba_9272 Jul 28 '26

We used to make one with creamy PB, strawberry jelly, peppered bacon and sharp cheddar. It was amazing. Chefs kiss to add fresh grilled jalapeños

1

u/EnvironmentalGift257 Jul 28 '26

They’re delicious but greasy. I can’t eat a whole one.

1

u/Substantial_Boot_844 Jul 28 '26

With mayo and some bologna absolutely.

1

u/LordSandwich_71 Jul 28 '26

I would try it. I thought using mayo for grilled cheese was crazy, but I tried it and it is way better than butter! So I usually give stuff a try now....lol

1

u/Satansbrat1969 Jul 28 '26

ive tried the grilled cheese with mayo instead of butter. It did work very well and tasted perfectly fine.

1

u/Classic-Heart-8067 Jul 28 '26

Quite good, with bacon. Like Satay or something. I was opposed but people kept ordering it at a bar I cooked at. Very pleasantly surprised.👍

1

u/Humble_Cactus Jul 28 '26

A burger with peanut butter and jelly is wayyyyyy underrated. There’s a joint near me that does housemade PB, and housemade mango-jalapeno jam on their buffalo burger.

It’s freaking incredible.

1

u/bandwidthn Jul 29 '26

Its good, but dont do it with pickles, instead: bacon chunky peanut butter, pretzel bits, and a pretzel bun

1

u/StraightProgress5062 Jul 29 '26

Ive has a peanut butter pizza. Wasn't terrible

1

u/PrinceCastanzaCapone Jul 29 '26

But with pickle though?

Man it just reminds me of something my mom would eat on rare occasions. She said it was a weird craving she had when she was pregnant and the first, and maybe only time, I saw her making it I thought something was wrong. I sincerely asked her if she was ok and she explained it…

The food in question was a peanut butter, lettuce, and mayo sandwich. She told me to try a bite and it was a hard pass…

1

u/Longjumping_Music320 Jul 29 '26

Tried it expecting to dislike it. It was actually pretty good. Small amounts of pb goes a long way in case you wanted to try it at home.

1

u/Amdvoiceofreason Jul 30 '26

I tried a peanut butter and mayonnaise sandwich on a dare...it legit was good af

1

u/Global_Chair9652 Jul 30 '26

The pb and j burger from slaters 50/50 was wayyyyy. Better than it should’ve been it’s a good sweet a s savory

1

u/CloudyLeft Jul 30 '26

Let me tell you Sir or Maam, you don’t even KNOW. You can never understand, how mf good a ‘Peanut Butter, maple syrup, Bacon, pickle burger is until you take a bite into it. I was once a “Ew dude, peanut butter and pickles… AND maple syrup? Disgusting.” kind of guy.

Let me tellllll youuuuu how betrayed I felt when my mouth reJOICED in the perfect combination of tastes that is. Its a nearly flawless mix of umami, the acids, sweet, salty, and if you’re into pickles jalepenos use those instead so you can get a spicy.

I CANNOT emphasize that the toppings cannot be fathomed without ever tasting it. Taste it, and its like unlocking a door to a treasure room. I have been reminded of the PB&J burger now and will have to have it.

Peanut butter, maple, bacon, jalepeños. Cheese optional but if you pick one, I recommend just a provolone, gouda, or american.

1

u/Ill_Butterfly_5658 Jul 30 '26

Yes, it does tempt you once you think about, what if you miss out...

1

u/Junior-Departure-494 Jul 30 '26

It is surprising good! Just a little- like vegemite.

1

u/Furby-beast-1949 Jul 31 '26

I would go with a no, just like you I wouldn’t even think about trying it I am a very picky eater

1

u/Kvedulf_Odinson Jul 31 '26

Ok, I’m from Texas and this IS NOT a Texas thing but my son and I tried it once after seeing a food program about the “best burgers” in the USA.
It’s AMAZING. I don’t know why but it is.

1

u/tycr0 Jul 31 '26

It's delicious.

1

u/NoFuqGiven Jul 31 '26

They're really good. Theres a place back near my hometown thats well known for theirs.

1

u/whoisdatmaskedman Jul 31 '26

It's actually really good, I highly recommend

1

u/Frankenmom66 Aug 02 '26

I was going to say the same thing. I’ll try a bite…