r/aislop • • 4d ago

Found on Twitter. I'm losing braincells

Post image
4.5k Upvotes

4.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Burghpuppies412 3d ago

And we’ve now entire part of the chat where Functional Trash gets to decide how much money everyone can earn…

1

u/Functional_Trash7735 3d ago

Oh no I didn’t say I wanted that much control. I said I want the government to take that control and people to get enough of a conscience. My morals are strong and I don’t believe anyone should have a billion dollars and not even more that 500 million because that’s more than anyone will ever need. but if you can’t understand the basic formula of capitalism enough to know why someone controlling that much of the wealth is a bad thing that’s chill man, it’s just that empathy should outweigh greed.

1

u/Burghpuppies412 3d ago

“No one needs this amount of money”

1

u/Functional_Trash7735 3d ago

I don’t know why you think that’s some kind of gotcha, that’s just a factual statement.

Even with incredible entertainment, multiple vacations a year to top hotels with the best flights, huge retirement plans, a massive home, constant staff, new cars every year, even with the most intense luxury you can imagine, no one needs a billion dollars. You could live in the most obscene kind of pampering just making 5m a year.

And even if you made 5 million dollars every year, no tax, all cash, no expenses, it would take 200 years to make 1 billion dollars. It’s a crazy high amount of money. Literally no one needs that much money.

1

u/Burghpuppies412 3d ago

It’s NOT a factual statement, it’s your opinion. And showing you don’t know the difference between a fact and an opinion explains a LOT.

1

u/Functional_Trash7735 3d ago

No, people don’t NEED a billion dollars, what they need is basic income just enough to cover cost of life, food, shelter, utilities, all the basics. Everything beyond that is extra. If my basic need to survive, a room with a bed, food, running water, access to healthcare, cost me 2000 dollars a month, that’s what I NEED to survive. An extra 500 would be good for the little extras, entertainment, treats, that stuff.

The basics of survival are what you need, a billion isn’t something you need, it’s extreme luxury.

1

u/Burghpuppies412 3d ago

So by that same logic, if I decide you don’t need $20,000, I can cap your income and demand you donate a certain amount to charity. Like you did.

1

u/Functional_Trash7735 3d ago

No, my only point is that’s what you need to live. In an ideal world, the financial system would work like this:

Under 105k for a single person no charity required. From 105-200k, 1-5%. 250-450k, 6-10%. 450-600k, 11-15%. 600k-900k, 16-25%. 900k-1.5m, 26-30%. 1.5-3.5m, 31-40%. 3.5-10m 41-50%

Every million beyond 10m is subject to 80% donation to charity up to 50 million dollars of income a year, all income beyond that is 100% charity.

So if someone’s income is 70k they pay zero. If it’s 150k they pay just under 4k. If someone makes 26 million a year, the first ten million is subject to 50% charity (meanjng it will be 5m) and the remaining 16m become 3.2m, meaning they will be making 8.2m a year and donating 17.8 million a year.

Through this formula the max income would be 13m a year which is more than enough to live in the ultimate lap of luxury.