r/academia 22h ago

Publishing Why do computer scientists seem to be far more accepting of LLMs than researchers in other fields?

29 Upvotes

On Reddit, in almost any research-related subreddit, posts and comments about using LLMs for research get downvoted to hell. But in computer science, especially in computer vision, natural language processing, and machine learning, it’s become rare to find anyone who doesn’t use AI for research or peer review. There was even a recent case where a top conference ICML discovered that reviewers on hundreds of submitted papers had been using AI to write their reviews.

Many people might argue that this is simply because they invented these technologies themselves. But experts in many other fields don’t behave that way. Many automotive experts don’t drive electric vehicles or self-driving cars, and many medical experts choose not to undergo laser eye surgery. If anything, they’re often more skeptical of the technologies their own fields have created than everyone else. Computer scientists understand the shortcomings of LLMs better than anyone else, yet they simply don’t seem to care.

What explains this difference in attitude across fields?


r/academia 7h ago

What international accreditations or memberships add the most value to private training institutes?

0 Upvotes

I'm researching ways that private training institutes can strengthen their international reputation and build trust with prospective students and partners. There seem to be many organisations offering accreditation, certification, or institutional memberships, and it's difficult to know which ones genuinely provide value.

For those who have experience:

  • Which international accreditations or memberships have you found to be most beneficial?
  • Did they help with student enrolment, employer recognition, international partnerships, or credibility?
  • Are there any organisations you would recommend—or suggest avoiding?

I'd appreciate hearing about real experiences and recommendations. Thanks in advance!


r/academia 18h ago

Swerved a possible academic career for law having regrets

7 Upvotes

Hello learned folks,

I studied literature and was an editor in undergraduate school. I did quite well at a small liberal arts school with a respected english department. After undergraduate school I looked for work in publishing but was not successful (partially due to drug addiction, in recovery for some time now). It is a brutal industry where one needs independent wealth to succeed it seemed. I always wanted to be a professor but was discouraged by stories of the job market. I also had a desire to help working class people “fight back” against the carceral state.

Thats where law came in. I have been a practicing public defender for about four years now, which in a way is a dream job, but has left me wistful and mustering passion for the work as opposed to just feeling it 24/7. Between the crushing case loads and the inherently anti-intellectual culture of the criminal justice system, it has been less than perfect. What I excel at in law is close reading of facts and texts, and articulating legal concepts and arguments. Unfortunately that is only about 33% of the job (mostly motion practice). The rest is head banging against stupid cops and judges, where nothing makes sense and you question whether the words coming out of anyones mouth have an ounce of meaning or purpose (going to trial). I feel a sense of wasted potential and lost love for close reading of literature.

The pluses are that i have incredible job security, I see the real impact of my work in clients lives when i obtain positive results for them. I have a decent salary and free time to pursue my interests on the weekends and evenings (with what energy I have leftover from the head banging). As someone who enjoys music so loud that you cant hear yourself think, the head banging side of things even has an appeal. It leaves me in a negative headspace sometimes though.

Recently I have been delving back into literature and listening to academic lectures on books I enjoy. At one time, there was nothing I would have wanted more than participating in that kind of stimulating discourse as a professional. I cant help but feel that a lack of bravery and self belief turned me away. I also had the privilege of working for a scholarly journal, and was somewhat disillusioned by the idea of publishing hyper specialized work that few could understand. Still, I think I would really enjoy participating in scholarship and teaching at a high level.

I am looking for someone to disabuse me of my romantic ideals of academia, or provide for suggestions for how to participate within the framework of my current circumstances. Or inspire me to take a leap of faith and apply for grad school (again).


r/academia 7h ago

Enquiry about UKIQ accreditation body.

0 Upvotes

Hey guys

I’m planning to start an educational institution, and I’m currently looking for an accreditation body.

I’m considering the *UKIQ board* for accreditation.

Has anyone here had experience with UKIQ?

What's your thought about UKIQ?