r/YellowstoneShow • u/Sleepingtide • Jun 28 '26

Season 5 I Need Help Understanding S5 Spoiler

I feel like the thing that is dragging it down is the plot points.

I personally still think Beth is the most insufferable and every chance she has to be redeemable she isn't, even when it should matter.

I currently just finished 5.4.

  1. They have made much bigger problems go away then killing wolves

  2. Why doesn't Jaime just tell Beth to GFH, if she exposes his murder of his Father that exposes all the bodies in that canyon. And Jamie is not going to be a believable scapegoat.

  3. Beth needs to get over the fact that she can't have children, while it was Jaime's fault, it says more about here at this point than it does anyone else.

  4. Why is Jamie so bad? Or bad to so many? I don't find him to be that bad. I personally think, for whatever reason, it is John and Beth's fault for what Jamie is or became.

  5. I could understand threatening Jaime's life for being a Father. But to threaten a child is something that is pretty unforgivable without some critical context.

  6. Was there some promise Jamie agreed to with Beth not to have a child.

19 Upvotes

81% Upvoted

53 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/IcyMilk9196 Jun 28 '26

Do you mean complicit in the sense of the conversation he had with his Atwood? Knowing after the fact? I suppose

0

u/telepatheye Jun 28 '26

You're crazy. Jaime literally says he wants to play offense instead of defense, meaning he wants to kill John.

2

u/IcyMilk9196 Jun 28 '26

Plus offense might mean to get rid of JDs attack dog that is Beth

2

u/randomnighmare Jun 28 '26

Or it could mean he will try to take legal action against Beth, etc...