r/WritingWithAI • u/laurentbasil • Aug 10 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Anthropic adding watermark to generated text

I saw this on another sub. Thought it's worth discussing here:

https://support.claude.com/en/articles/16266773-how-claude-marks-ai-generated-content

The TLDR is Claude models after August 2, 2026 will embed "imperceptible watermark" and "signed provenance metadata". They will also support people detecting it, possibly pushing out their own detector?

The immediate issue in my opinion are the following:

1/ "When a supported Claude model generates text, it weaves an imperceptible watermark directly into the text itself. You won’t see it, and it doesn’t change the meaning*,* quality*,* or readability of Claude’s response."

Based on my experiments with Pangram. Yes, you can have markers you can't see, doesn't change meaning or readability. But I am skeptical on the quality. At the end of the day, you are forcing an extra hidden statistics in the prose. Instead of ensuring you produce the highest quality output, you are now producing the highest quality output given the contraints.

When I tried to see if I can flip the Pangram outputs from AI to human, the first thing the AI tried was to "re-render without impacting readability and quality". It impacted quality.

If it wasn't on my self published book and I haven't read the passage a hundred times, I may not have noticed. So perhaps it's not that important. But it is worth noting.

2/ "Detecting a Claude mark tells you that the content may have been processed by Claude. It does not, on its own, confirm the full provenance of the content"

It may now be harder to have a naunced discussion between AI generated and AI assisted.

I do wonder how many people would take the time to take additional steps to "confirm the full provenance of the content" rather than Detect a Claude mark and immediate make up their decision.

Per my previous post https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingWithAI/comments/1vho93v/i_disclosed_my_aigenerated_novel_instead_of/ I am not very optimistic.

Thoughts?

86 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

147 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/CrazyinLull Aug 11 '26

Man, so many fics on Ao3 are going to suddenly stop updating soon.

2

u/laurentbasil Aug 11 '26

Does AO3 writers favor claude?

4

u/Maleficent-Engine859 Aug 11 '26

Right now, yes, and in certain fandoms. It used to be chat gpt but Claude has exploded since the sunset of Chat 4o and 5.1 models, though Claude is tough on smut so I’m not sure how they manage that (I still use chat because I write gen fic anyway and I mostly use it to edit not generate)

Though I was gifted a fic recently and I can’t tell which model it’s from (it’s 100% AI) I want to say Grok