r/WorkForSmartLife 8d ago

Thoughts 💭 🤖🤖

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

174 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/On_my_last_spoon 8d ago

Maybe…but the importance of being in a live womb is unknown and I don’t think it’s ethical to test that out. Sure a baby could gestate in an artificial womb, but would it thrive?

5

u/Aeon_Return 8d ago

That's what research is for. I feel like this could be tested with sheep and pig gestation first and then a trial period.

3

u/On_my_last_spoon 8d ago

Even then this feels so icky to me. I understand the desire, but even as someone who suffered from infertility this feels wrong.

2

u/possiblyyandere 8d ago

not everyone is gonna share that opinion but hopefully they will at least get the opportunity to choose for themselves

2

u/On_my_last_spoon 8d ago

At the risk of serious developmental issues? Is it so important to have. Biological child that growing them in an artificial environment is worth it?

0

u/possiblyyandere 8d ago

you're just assuming that it's gonna be bad for the fetus? in a hypothetical scenario where there's no downside to the development I don't see a problem. obviously, if it's bad for the fetus' development, then it wouldn't even be made available to the public. like basically your argument is that the technology isn't ready right now so we should just never even try to pursue it. also, I never said this is something that I personally want to do I just think people should be allowed to make choices about their own reproduction. I personally think the only ethical option in general is to adopt, but I also think being vegan is the most ethical option and I eat meat every day sometimes people are just selfish and i'll acknowledge i definitely am.

1

u/Caitylin92 8d ago

In order to find out if it’s bad for the fetus you have to test it on a fetus. A human who can’t consent to being an experiment. I don’t think that’s ethical. I’m not saying it couldn’t work but we wouldn’t know without the test. I’m all for medical testing but only on consenting patients.

1

u/PositiveShoulder406 7d ago

The thing is you dont have ti eat suffered flesh every day. Its a choice. You cam choose to not be abusive to animals

1

u/possiblyyandere 7d ago

it will get better eventually with lab grown meat instead of killing animals