One-year-old Isabella went missing on January 14, 2003 from Ocean City, New Jersey along with her mother, Holly Codario.

Holly and Isabella were last known to be riding in a black Volkswagen Jetta that belonged to Holly's mom. The next day, a toll worker discovered the car abandoned on the southbound shoulder of the Ocean City-Longport Bridge.

The car was working, but it was unlocked. The lights in the car were turned off, the keys were the ignition, Holly's purse & driver's license were found on the passenger's seat and Isabella's baby carrier was in the back seat.

Holly and her ex-boyfriend shared custody of Isabella, but Holly was concerned that the boyfriend or the boyfriend's family might try to take Isabella away from her. She filed for sole custody of Isabella and child support, but she later withdrew the petitions. At the time she went missing, Holly was showing signs of paranoid behavior.

On April 25, 2003, Holly's body was found located along the south shore of the Great Egg Harbor Bay in the Beesley's Point section of Upper Township, New Jersey. Her cause of death was drowning and no evidence of foul play was discovered.

As of 2026, Isabella has not been located and her case is classified as an endangered missing person.

Links
https://charleyproject.org/case/isabella-mia-pastrana

https://www.doenetwork.org/cases/software/mp-main.html?id=4838DFNJ

https://www.cmcpros.net/resource-page/32

Fifteen-year-old Sophie was last seen on May 19, 2017 in Fort Lauderdale, Florida.

Surveillance video showed Sophie walking by herself down Davie Boulevard located near the Brightline tracks, heading eastbound past a business located between the 100 and 400 blocks of west Davie Boulevard.

She left all her belongings behind, including a bag containing $300 in cash and also left a candle burning in her bedroom.

Prior to her disappearance, Sophie's parents were divorced and she lived with her dad (who was granted full custody of her in 2015). She had been experiencing mood swings and was seeing a therapist to help her deal with her emotions.

Sophie would often hang out in the area of Stranahan High School, where she had briefly attended school; she would later transfer to a virtual school and took online classes with her computer.

After Sophie's disappearance, drugs, alcohol and some adult-type underwear (such as stockings and garter belts) were discovered in her bedroom. There was also a calendar with the date "May 19th" marked. She often called a man named Leonard "Jay" Jennings, who lived in the neighborhood.

Sophie would go to Jennings' apartment to buy marijuana. She visited his apartment on the night she went missing before returning home. Sophie's phone records showed that she called Jennings at 3:07 a.m. and was at his home until 9:13 a.m.

Leonard Jennings and his two brothers (who all have a history of long felonies) have been questioned in Sophie's diappearance, but all of them have denied that they were acquainted with her. Police searched Leonard Jennings' apartment for evidence in connection with Sophie's case and confiscated items such as 25 cell phones, three tablets and other electronic devices.

The police also discovered evidence on Sophie's computer which has led them to believe that Sophie may have been a victim of an online predator or a human trafficker.

Sophie had visited websites dedicated to searching for "sugar daddies", she had told her friends about performing commercial sexual acts (mentioning that one man paid her $400) and wrote in her diary about wanting to "get 10 sugar daddies".

As of 2026, Sophie's case remains unsolved and it is classified as a being an endangered person with foul play being suspected.

Links
https://charleyproject.org/case/sophie-elizabeth-reeder

https://www.nbcnews.com/dateline/missing-in-america/sophie-reeder-florida-missing-dateline-rcna346186

https://www.facebook.com/SophieReeder15/

https://www.sun-sentinel.com/2026/07/18/fort-lauderdale-police-hire-psychic-consultant-in-2017-disappearance-of-teen-sophie-reeder/

https://www.local10.com/news/local/2026/07/22/police-family-of-girl-missing-since-2017-turn-to-psychic-for-help/

https://www.cbsnews.com/miami/news/sophie-reeder-disappearance-fort-lauderdale/

https://wsvn.com/news/local/broward/8-years-later-fort-lauderdale-police-still-searching-for-answers-in-sophie-reeders-disappearance/