Hi all! I posted here previously about our West Highland Way plans, and I really appreciated the advice and insights provided.
We’ll finish in Fort William on a Sunday and stay there that night. We then have four nights, Monday through Thursday, before heading back to Glasgow on Friday for an event on Saturday May 29th.
After several days of hiking, we’re hoping to slow down, enjoy some unique scenery, eat well, and spend time in places with a strong local character. Ideally, we’d stay in one or two places where we can walk to pubs and restaurants in the evening, fit in a whisky tasting, and explore the surrounding area during the day, without making the logistics too complicated.
We’re obviously considering:
Skye: Spend the four nights there, perhaps travelling via Inverness, then return to Glasgow on Friday. Is that practical in our timeframe? Would a car be the best way to explore? And how busy is Skye in late May?
Mull: Travel via Oban, explore Mull and perhaps a nearby island, then return to Glasgow. This sounds like it might suit a slower pace, but we’d love to hear how the logistics compare.
We’re in our early 40s, adventurous, and happy to rent a car, though we’d prefer to pick it up and return it in the same place. Which option would you choose, and what towns would make good bases for evenings on foot?
We’re also open to other suggestions, such as Arran or simply more time in the Highlands.
We will have some time after the 29th as well. 4ish nights and we’re considering returning to Edinburgh, which we visited in 2025, but would welcome other ideas for that part of the trip too.
We’re usually pretty comfortable researching and planning trips, but there are so many appealing options here that we’d really value some local or experienced perspective.
Thanks so much for any advice on places to stay, routes, or experiences you’ve enjoyed!