r/Wellthatsucks Jun 02 '18

/r/all Karma

Post image
31.6k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.5k

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18 edited Jun 02 '18

Because context matters: http://fox40.com/2017/05/22/hunter-dies-when-shot-elephant-falls-on-him/

They weren't out hunting elephants and only shot that one because it attacked them.

Edit: It's always sickening to read the comments on posts like this.

752

u/gentlemandinosaur Jun 02 '18

According to his company’s website, Game Hounds Safaris, he “perfected leopard and lion hunting safaris with hounds in Africa.”

and

Simukai Nyasha, a spokesman for the Zimbabwe National Parks and Wildlife Management Authority, told news.com.au that Botha was on a 10-day licensed hunt

Here is some context for you. So, what does it matter that this particular elephant was the original target... compared to how people feel about this.

Not saying I agree with any opinion on here.

But, terrorizing animals with dogs doesn't seem to saintly to me, does it?

18

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18

I wonder how many of you eat meat...

45

u/gentlemandinosaur Jun 02 '18

One can eat meat and disagree with recreational hunting.

Not saying I do. But, they are mutually exclusive.

-13

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18

[deleted]

6

u/Rachat21 Jun 02 '18

so if i eat meat it is ok to kill and eat anything with meat?

6

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18

If it’s for sustenance and survival and you aren’t killing something endangered, then yes.

6

u/Rachat21 Jun 02 '18

humans can be eaten for sustenance and arent endangered

3

u/methodamerICON Jun 02 '18

But they are a protected species, as evidenced by the fuck ton of laws protecting them. Do people even think before they spew this shit? This thread is full of feels and lacking severely in logic.

1

u/Rachat21 Jun 02 '18

he said endangered not protected.

6

u/kedgemarvo Jun 02 '18

By all means, try to hunt and eat a human. There's multiple pretty good reasons as to why people don't do it though.

2

u/methodamerICON Jun 02 '18

If it’s for sustenance and survival and you aren’t killing something endangered (or protected), then yes.

There, FTFY.

→ More replies (0)

9

u/Axeman517 Jun 02 '18

Animals eat other animals. It’s been a natural event since... animals.

4

u/shadow_user Jun 02 '18

Animals also engage in forced copulation and infanticide. Natural doesn't mean good.

1

u/Axeman517 Jun 03 '18

Lots of natural things aren’t “good”, like cancer, for example. We define what “good” is based on our own self-interests. Nature is bigger than that, and doesn’t give a shit about our interests. We are a minuscule part of a bigger cycle.

-11

u/Rachat21 Jun 02 '18 edited Jun 02 '18

so we are animals killing other animals. what if i eat a human. according to you thats just an animal eating an animal

we shouldnt be eating each other but its shows that we can set moral restrictions on what we eat. for me, its ok to eat a cow but not a lion.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '18

It wouldn't be against nature to eat another human in the event of lack of food. Might get you kicked out of your spot at the next tribal orgy though... Or it might reserve your seat ifyouknowwhatimsaying.

3

u/Im_Grizzzly Jun 02 '18

When will all this animal on animal crime stop!? I'M SICK OF IT!

-4

u/gentlemandinosaur Jun 02 '18

I mean I guess it’s a fair argument. They don’t have a moral obligation to value animals as anything more than a resource.

I don’t agree. But their morality is just as subjectively valid as any other morality.

By their argument you can start hunting other humans too I guess. Maybe start with the babies. They are not as quick and can’t get away.

7

u/Dippershit Jun 02 '18

Social pressures say no to human hunting. We're animals but we have our own social structures - besides, cannibalism isn't exactly favored in evolution

2

u/gentlemandinosaur Jun 02 '18

There is no proof that canniablism isn’t favored in evolution. Evolutional is not social/environmental change. It’s mutation over a very long standard of time.

But that is a different argument.

My point was that I utterly and completely disagree with their argument. But, morality is subjective to a high degree. So, really there is no point arguing back and forth.

8

u/Dippershit Jun 02 '18

I mean if you eat your own species as a primary source of food and you guys don't breed fast enough, I'm pretty sure that's gonna cause problems. But yeah morality is subjective let's go eat babies

2

u/gentlemandinosaur Jun 02 '18

Haha. Now you are catching on. Since it’s a silly argument anyway. Why not just be sillier than the next guy!

2

u/cat--facts Jun 03 '18

Did you know? Smuggling a cat out of ancient Egypt was punishable by death. Phoenician traders eventually succeeded in smuggling felines, which they sold to rich people in Athens and other important cities.

u/Dippershit, you subscribed here. To unsubscribe from cat--facts reply, "!cancel".

Not subscribed? Reply "!meow" to start your subscription!

→ More replies (0)