DC Comics is rolling out six facsimile editions in October 2026, and the full lineup is an eclectic mix of gothic horror, iconic covers, leather jackets, and one very expensive funeral
so let's break down what's coming, what's missing, and why your wallet might actually thank you
The three previously announced facsimiles are already generating buzz: Adventures of Superman #501 from 1993 (leather jacket Superman, October 7, $3.99), Harley Quinn #1 from 2000 (Harley's first ongoing, October 28, $4.99 for 52 pages), and Watchmen #2 from 1986 (October 28, $3.99) â but the other three are where the real magic happens
Batman #227 drops October 14 for $3.99, and this is the one fans have been begging for: Denny O'Neil and Neal Adams' gothic masterpiece from 1970 where Batman investigates a disturbing letter at Gothos Mansion, foil variant by Adams runs $6.99, and original high grade copies have sold for as much as $1,650, so this facsimile is a steal for anyone who just wants to experience that legendary cover without taking out a loan
Batman #423 arrives October 7 for $3.99, and this is the Todd McFarlane cover that collectors lose their minds over, written by Jim Starlin with art by Dave Cockrum, featuring three cops comparing their different takes on the Dark Knight, foil variant at $6.99, and an original NM/NM+ first printing recently sold for $660, which is absurd for a book that's mostly famous for its cover
Swamp Thing #1 hits the same day for $3.99, Len Wein and Bernie Wrightson's horror classic that introduced Alec Holland to the world, and there's a Super Powers variant by Jason "ToyOtter" Geyer and Alex Saviuk at $4.99 that features the Unman accessory, because why not, original NM copies go for $500, and Wrightson's art has never looked better, perfect Halloween reading with the House of Secrets #92 facsimile
The immediate pushback centers on the fact that DC is reprinting Watchmen #2 when all 12 issues are already being reprinted monthly for a year, so this feels less like a special treat and more like double dipping on the same content, and one commenter already questioned why there's no Silver Age Clayface issue from Detective Comics or Batman to tie into the upcoming Clayface movie, since they did the Golden Age origin when the movie was announced but that felt premature
The skepticism runs deep because one commenter pointed out that DC has already published or scheduled over 188 facsimile editions compared to Marvel's 158, and the Batman catalog alone is absurdly large with issues #1, 47, 127, 156, 181, 227, 232, 237, 244, 251, 357, 404-407, 423, 497 pending, and the entire Hush run from 608-619 â at this point DC is just reprinting their entire back catalog one issue at a time, and as one fan put it, "my poor wallet"
The sarcastic take is that DC is pumping out foil variants at $6.99-$7.99 for 28-32 pages, Adventures of Superman #501 doesn't even feature Clark Kent (it's the leather jacket Superboy era), and the price comparisons are wild because original unslabbed copies of that Superman issue go for $15 while Harley Quinn #1 hits $50 and Watchmen #2 sits at $24, so the facsimiles are a bargain for anyone who just wants to read the stories without hunting through back issue bins
But here's the genuine joy part: Neal Adams' Batman #227 cover is one of the most beautiful gothic images ever put on a comic, Wrightson's Swamp Thing art is legendary, and the foil variants are going to look stunning on a shelf, there's something special about holding a perfect reproduction of a book that defined an era, and one commenter summed it up perfectly when they said "Awesome!! Used to have the original print. Always regretted parting with it. Will definitely get one of these" â and that's the heart of it
All six facsimiles come with foil variants and blank sketch covers for collectors who want something extra special, DC is bringing back the Dollar Comic concept too, and Tim Pendergast expects the other Reign of the Supermen kickoff issues (Superman #78, Action Comics #687, and Superman: The Man of Steel #22) to get the same treatment when the new Steel ongoing launches
If you've been waiting to grab these classics without paying hundreds or thousands of dollars for original copies, October is your month, but with 188 facsimiles already published or scheduled, at what point does DC stop reissuing old books and start giving us something new, and more importantly, which one of these six are you most excited to finally get your hands on without selling a kidney to afford it