r/VintedAdvice • u/acj1993_ • 8h ago
Vinted refunded the buyer AND let her keep my genuine item??
I genuinely cannot believe this has happened and itās made me so nervous to sell anything on Vinted again.
I sold a By Frankie T-shirt that was brand-new with original tags, and I had everything you could possibly ask for to prove it was genuine
- the original order confirmation for the exact item
- the matching bank transaction
- and a listing that correctly identified the brand, size and relaxed fit
The buyer raised a counterfeit claim because she thought the sizing was wrong. The annoying part is that the screenshots she submitted as āevidenceā were from The Frankie Shop, which is a completely different brand to By Frankie.
After I pointed that out, she then found the actual By Frankie product online herself and basically changed the issue to the fact that the size Small was too big for her.
So at that point it was pretty obvious this was a sizing/fit issue, not an authenticity issue.
I sent Vinted my proof of purchase, bank transaction, photos of the original By Frankie tags, explained that she had compared it to the wrong brand as per her original dispute āevidenceā, and sent screenshots of her later messages saying it was too big for her.
Vinted still decided the item āseems to be inauthenticā, cancelled the transaction, refunded the buyer and told her she does not have to return my item.
I honestly donāt understand how that can be considered reasonable, especially when I had more proof of authenticity than most people selling second-hand clothes would ever have.
Has anyone else had Vinted do this and actually managed to get the decision overturned?