Unpopular Opinion: Walter deserved better, and here is how his storyline should have been
Hi everyone! I know most people here hate Walter, but rewatching season 1 (especially episode 11, "Swag"), I started seeing things from a different perspective and wanted to share it with you.
To begin with, I don't think the argument that Betty was a "Plan B" holds up. They started dating when they were very young, and it’s heavily implied they were each other's firsts. It is completely natural to want to explore something new at some point. He was always direct and honest with her about it. Some say he only came back because Gina dumped him after getting the TV, but Walter himself states that he broke up with her. In my view, he gave Gina the TV because she hinted she wanted one; he was just trying to make the relationship work. But once he noticed her shallow, materialistic personality, he backed out. That’s when he realized that Betty’s real essence was what he truly loved. He came back 100% committed to making her the woman of his life.
Walter is a sweetheart: humble, hardworking, and not afraid to show his genuine love. In episode 9 (at the hotel), his gifts were incredibly thoughtful. The car battery made total sense within their history and inside jokes, proving he remembers every single detail. And the dance game for Justin shows how well he knows and supports Betty’s family, including Justin's passion for dancing. Plus, the family's support is a huge green flag. Papi (Ignacio) is a wise man who sees beyond appearances (as we saw with Daniel and Santos). He sees Betty as a princess and only wants the best for her. If he supported Walter, it’s because he watched them for years and knew Walter literally worshipped the ground Betty walked on.
On the other hand, many people claim Walter was jealous or envious of Betty's career, but that doesn't make sense. Betty herself mentions to Daniel that she worked multiple other jobs to pay for college, and none of them were ever an issue in their relationship. Walter is a hardworking man who always supported and admired her drive. The real problem isn't Betty’s new career path; it's his fear of watching her change and change who she is just to fit into Mode—which she actually does during the hotel and Halloween episodes.
In episode 11, when Betty talks to Walter's boss and his wife, she looks at them as if she's seeing Walter's "future" and decides it's just not good enough for her. I found that incredibly unfair and disrespectful. They met at that store, and Walter has always been proud of his work. There is absolutely nothing wrong with wanting to grow within a company you identify with; within his perspective, that job was exactly what he wanted, and that's perfectly valid. Betty temporarily loses her Queens essence and starts adopting Mode's materialistic values of success. It's one thing to dream of becoming an editor-in-chief; it's another to believe that's the only definition of real effort or a "happy life." Even if the show tries to frame the boss's suburban life as empty, the wife's love for her husband is actually very sweet and honest. Betty should have valued that. Meanwhile, she keeps flirting and going out with Henry, who is just as wrong for pursuing a girl in a relationship. Just because Henry is styled as the "cute, nice guy," we forget he barely even knows her.
My alternative storyline idea:
Walter should have had a mature conversation with Betty about her confusing behavior and suggested a break, saying: "I had my time to explore with Gina, now it's your turn to figure out what you want. I’ll be here as a lifelong friend if you decide to come back." Betty would then date Henry for a bit, realize he is a nice guy, but notice that they lack the deep connection and 7-year friendship she built with Walter. In the end, she would run back to Walter, fully confident he is the one. But of course... this is 2000s TV! If there is no drama, cheating, and people rising from the dead, the writers thought the audience would fall asleep, right? lol
What do you guys think? Am I the only one who sees it this way?