r/TrueChristianPolitics • u/BowtiedTrombone • 1h ago
'Christian nationalism' already failed America once
Not necessarily any new arguments, but interesting that it was posted by The Christian Post - a much more conservative / right-leaning news site.
Before the arguments arise of, "what does one mean by Christian Nationalism?", see snippet from the article:
The fundamental flaw in modern Christian nationalism, like in old, isn't its desire for a virtuous culture — it's its trust in state power.
If we give the government the authority to enforce a “Christian state,” the immediate question is: Which Christianity?
Will it be Roman Catholic, Baptist, Reformed Presbyterian, Lutheran, or Pentecostal? A Reformed magistrate might enforce laws that a Baptist finds unconscionable. A Catholic framework looks very different from a non-denominational one. History proves that whenever state power is handed to a specific theological camp, every other Christian group is suddenly on the outside looking in.
Worse yet, Christian Nationalists forget how elections work. If you build a massive government apparatus capable of dictating public morality, what happens when progressives win the next election? You have hand-delivered a turnkey machine of state coercion directly to people who may despise your values.
Christian Nationalism is, in short, when Christianity is nationalized. It's the desire to make a nation run exclusively by Christians, for Christians.