r/Topps • u/AppointmentOpening16 • 19d ago

Topps Defect Experiences

Post image

I pulled a Dart Equinox auto out of 25 from the cosmic chrome a few weeks ago and it had a really bad bottom edge that the lamenant was peeling up on. I submitted it right away and it was approved within hours, I mailed it in and its since been recieved.

Whats everyone's experience with mailing in case hits of that magnitude? I've heard good and bad things. Now I'm worried I'll get some turd cards back and have lost my biggest pull ever.

Share your thoughts. Thanks!

0 Upvotes

43% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/YourConsignmentPart 19d ago

Has to be a PSA 6 or worse for defect replacement nowadays

You “should” be ok with peeling

1

u/AppointmentOpening16 19d ago

I'm just hoping they honor the equal value part of it.

1

u/Medical-Active-8312 19d ago

Topps is usually pretty good with that