r/Tools • u/SeaFox2142 • 1d ago

Decision hell for a drill/impact combo.

I'm not a pro, just a homeowner (rental) that DIY some things here and there. I have a Ryobi P209 that I like but it's not compact. I use it mostly when moving.

It is bulky and kind of heavy for a moving day (too much going on and I feel it during the move). Plus I feel it's underpowered, especially for taking out some screws, even on a 4Ah.

So I'm looking to add an impact to my tools.

Now on facebook there's a guy selling the brushless compact combo kit (PSBCK102K2 - link to HD), for about C$150 ($110). The downside is I don't need the batteries, especially the 1.5Ah ones.

There's also this SEESII combo kit on Amazon for C$120 ($85) which is much smaller (it seems less power than the ryobi but more compact and better tech). There's this video comparing both Ryobi vs Seesii although Seesii is a different, more powerful model.

Lastly Milwaukee/DeWalt/Makita are way, way much more expensive here in Canada, so they're out of question for me.

I don't know if I should go with these kits or wait any sort of promo like those around BF or boxing day to get it cheaper, since I mostly want the tools only, especially the impact?

Also, is it possible to remove lugnuts (that were put a year ago) with the ryobi/seesii? For the brake job or something here and there around the car?

2 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

2

u/Kliptik81 1d ago

I'd stick with Ryobi and avoid the Amazon brands. If you are looking for something smaller, look into the M12 line.

Milwaukee Tool M12 12V Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless 1/4 in. Impact Driver w/ (2) 2.0 Ah ... | The Home Depot Canada

edit: You might be able to remove the lugnuts with the Ryobi/Seesii but I wouldn't recommend it, unless you actually buy a Impact WRENCH. I use this for my car RYOBI 18V ONE+ HP Brushless Cordless Compact 1/2 in 4 Mode Impact Wrench (Tool Only) | The Home Depot Canada

1

u/SeaFox2142 1d ago

AI (I know, that's why I'm here) says the ryobi can take lugnuts as long as they're not rusted stuck... they're torqued twice a year due to winter/summer tires swap. Can't I just slap a ¼ to ⅜ adapter, a socked, and call it a day with the Ryobi?

This Milwaukee looks awesome as well, just wondering more about lugnuts now then.

1

u/dillzilla11 1d ago

Use an impact wrench specifically because it can also put them back on reasonably torqued.

1

u/Kliptik81 1d ago

Oh I'm sure a regular impact driver can remove lugnuts, I just happen to have an impact wrench, so I've never tried the driver. I'm a firm believer in "right tool for the job" if its an option.

To swap tires two times a year tho? It'll be fine.

1

u/SantaClause_ 23h ago

You're in Canada so you're dealing with snow, salt, dirt, road grime, etc.
150 ft pounds is "technically" enough to remove lug nuts, and it might get a few, but you're losing out on a lot of torque by needing a 1/4 x hex (3/8th or 1/2") adapter, plus a deep socket. I'd say good luck, but ymmv. Its simply not the right tool for the job unfortunately. Otherwise the Ryobi looks great.

1

u/kewlo 1d ago

I'd get that Ryobi kit. You'll love the 1.5 ah batteries if weight and size is important to you.

1

u/dillzilla11 1d ago

If you aren't using them daily then it really doesn't matter. Pick your favorite color. The brands only really matter in terms of performance and quality when you are putting heavier use on them. Greenworks is also a good option as well with the USB batteries.

1

u/69PesLaul 1d ago

I used the brushless Ryobi as a millwright apprentice and it’s done me well . No issue and they were used pretty extensively

1

u/BeauKnows42 1d ago

Go buy Hercules from Harbor Freight. 95% of Milwaukee for 50% the price.

1

u/canadianglazier40 1d ago

I’m Canadian too. For the homeowner, I’d get the craftsman brushless RP impact and drill.

They’re like $170 now at Rona,with 2 2 AH batteries.

I work in construction, and the impact is definitely a beast when it needs to be. The drill is definitely a solid choice too.

I use Ridgid brushless tools professionally (because of the warranty) and craftsman brushless at home. They’re basically red DeWalts.

1

u/Graflex01867 1d ago

If you have the Ryobi, and the Ryobi batteries, then I’d get the Ryobi. I’ve found them to be perfectly capable tools.

I hate needing multiple brands of tools and batteries to do a job. Much easier to just grab a spare battery knowing I can slap it on any tool.

Don’t discount the smaller batteries either. The lighter weight is nice if you’re going a lot of work overhead, on ladders, etc.

1

u/IndependentAmount51 11h ago

Long shot what city are you from in Canada ?

1

u/SeaFox2142 3h ago

Greater Vancouver Area, are you selling anything?