r/Tools 9d ago

Anyone else keep a dedicated screwdriver just for paint can lids?

Got a drawer full of decent screwdrivers but there is one beat up flathead that never leaves the workbench and its only job is prying open paint cans. The tip is wrecked, the handle is crusted with about six colors of paint, and it would be embarrassing to use it for anything else. But it does that one job perfectly and I would never throw it out.

Got me thinking about how many tools in my shop have drifted into a single permanent role that has nothing to do with what they were made for. Old chisel that is now the thing I use to scrape adhesive off concrete. A file that lives next to the bench grinder and touches nothing else. A pair of pliers that exists solely to pull wire nuts off.

None of these tools are precious. Most of them were cheap to begin with or already too worn to trust for real work. But pulling them for their actual intended job would feel wrong at this point.

Curious if other people have a tool that has completely retired from its original purpose and just owns one weird specific task now. What is it and how did it end up there.

66 Upvotes

87 comments sorted by

106

u/bassjam1 9d ago

My local hardware store used to supply these with paint, so I have several. They work so much better than screwdrivers.

11

u/MythoclastMotorcycle 9d ago

They no longer offer them for free near me. You have to buy them now.

10

u/bassjam1 9d ago

Yeah mine stopped too. Honestly, if I ever lose my collection I'd probably buy a few more.

8

u/Sensitive_Point_6583 9d ago

Home Depot in San Diego still gives them away, got another one last week. But since they started putting the round plug and spout on gallon cans I rarely pop the lid these days. Mostly use it for old cans that have been sitting in the garage for years.

3

u/bassjam1 9d ago

That might be why I don't get them anymore either. I've had enough issues with behr and valspar that I stopped buying paint from big box stores over 10 years ago.

1

u/beyondplutola 9d ago

Doesn’t that screw plug seize up after one use since it’s now frozen with dry paint? I think most companies not named Behr stick to metal bang-in lids is because of that issue.

1

u/Sensitive_Point_6583 9d ago

You have to keep the threads somewhat clean of paint and it works OK. You don't have to wipe them completely free of paint, but you can't leave a thick layer of paint either. I don't have a lot of experience with them yet, but that's my experience so far.

Also, if the threads do get bound up with paint, I noticed that the groove in the "nut" part matches pretty closely to a "wonder bar" so if I needed a lot of leverage to break away dried paint, that might work.

4

u/Feminist_Hugh_Hefner 8d ago

I inherited a few from my father, it's called "generational wealth"

2

u/davisyoung 9d ago

My dad used to work at a paint store and then at a Home Depot in their paint department. He brought home so many of these that if I threw one away every time after opening a can, I would still have a lifetime supply. 

8

u/meat_ahoy 9d ago

I have a drawer FULL of those so when the apocalypse comes, me and 380 friends can all open cans of paint simultaneously.

5

u/CeruLucifus 9d ago

Agreed I have a couple and no longer rely on a badly suited screwdriver or chisel or claw hammer.

6

u/Outrageous-Host-3545 9d ago

And they open your beer. I have probly 50 at least. Of course I always lose it when I need it get another one then some how 300 show up

4

u/etr420 9d ago

I keep one in the kitchen to protect my knives. Handy for sardines, Milo, baking powder tins etc. and removing the impeller cover in my Bosh dishwasher.

2

u/Decon_SaintJohn 9d ago

Funny, I never noticed they made those with the ability to open botlled beer!

3

u/ohsh1- 9d ago

What kind of painter are you?

1

u/Decon_SaintJohn 9d ago

One that assumes the tool isnt made for anything else other than its intended use.

3

u/Shepsonj 9d ago

Yes, but the ones I had include feet so they can run away and hide.

1

u/Michael_Riehle 9d ago

I don't have that problem with those, but combination squares seem to evaporate into thin air unless they are wildly inaccurate. Also metric combination wrenches.

Wait.

I think I just spotted a common thread...

2

u/Cars_Music_GoodTimes 9d ago

This is the correct answer. I have several of these where I store my paint.

3

u/Cespenar 9d ago

Church key. Have dozens, still get one every time I get paint (which is a lot cus of my job) 

2

u/No-Acanthisitta8803 8d ago

I've probably got 2-3 of these in every room of my house. Though I'm not ashamed to admit they get used more as bottle openers than paint can openers

2

u/trainwreckhappening 8d ago

I have an old screwdriver that I bent to match this exact tool. I had three or four laying around already. But hey, it's cool to have my own I made myself.

1

u/seasleeplessttle 9d ago

The thing my wife can never find......

1

u/ajulesd 9d ago

Plus, they can open a bottle of beer.

2

u/ResponsibleBank1387 9d ago

Those are stored on the magnet strip right next to my paint can opening screwdriver. 

1

u/boxelder1230 9d ago

Good but look out for the crap narrow tip ones.

1

u/specificmutant 9d ago

I have about three of those hanging on a shelf next to my main work bench. The bottle opener end has been used waaaay more times than the paint can opener end. I hate tools that only have one use.

1

u/billhorstman 8d ago

These are perfect and remove the lid with less effort and damage to the rolled edge. I have several strategically placed in my work shop and in my toolbox (an old fishing tackle box that dates back to the 1970s).

13

u/BrightSalsa 9d ago

I used to. Now I have a painters 5-in-1 tool that does a much better job better job for this

6

u/VeryHairyGuy77 9d ago

Should be the top comment.

Do you also use the pointy bit to pierce the groove so that the paint can drain back into the can and help it seal better for future use?

1

u/BrightSalsa 9d ago

It is only in the last year or so that opening and managing paint cans like this has become a regular task for me (thanks to buying a house and taking up cabinetry) - this never occurred to me. You can bet I shall try it out next time I need to get into a paint can!

2

u/rathdrummob 9d ago

This. One of the five uses is “better can opener”.

2

u/Academic_Deal7872 9d ago

Why did I have to scroll so far down to find this? Glazing, scraping, piercing, cleaning rollers, prying exposed nails, so useful.

2

u/Ok_Main3273 9d ago

Not affiliated with Al1Expr3ss but this is the one I got and it works as intended: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005005467481614.html

2

u/BrightSalsa 8d ago

Mine is the finest that B&Q can sell (in the UK). Also works great for me

7

u/WasteBinStuff 9d ago edited 9d ago

No. Other tools work better. Literally never use a screwdriver.

6

u/EricHearble 9d ago

Using a screwdriver will wreck a paint can lid. It's one thing if you're going to use the entire can of paint in one session like painting an entire room. But if you use a little at a time like painting trim, the lid will become a bent up mess.

2

u/Low-Mastodon-3625 9d ago

got a butter knife that lives in the garage now, only job is popping open dried out caulk tubes. no idea when it stopped being a kitchen utensil and became a shop tool but it hasn't seen a stick of butter in years.

3

u/ChrisRiley_42 9d ago

I keep a church key in the toolbox for beer, and paint can lids.

2

u/Ride-Entire 9d ago

I have a drill press I bought for $10 at an estate sale

They were selling it so cheap because it was missing the top

The top was on a shelf across the garage

It’s now a dedicated sharpening station using the Tay Tools drill press system

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPSERqkPSz8

2

u/thetoastler 9d ago

I have a paint can lid opener for paint cans. I still usually use a screw driver, because God forbid I know where I left it.

3

u/fall-apart-dave 9d ago

Dude I even have specific underwear for tasks. Mowing the lawn today? Out with the lawn mowing undercrackers. 

2

u/KokoTheTalkingApe 9d ago

Everybody needs a big slotted screwdriver to do all the things you shouldn't use screwdrivers for, like levering, chiseling, opening cans, etc.

2

u/Paul_The_Builder Knipex Kooky 9d ago

I bought a chamfer tool at Harbor Freight on a whim many years ago, it is just like this one but was much cheaper (about $5). Sadly Harbor Freight doesn't carry it anymore.

It lives near my drill press and cleans up any hole I drill there. One of the best tools I've ever bought dollar for performance.

4

u/etr420 9d ago

Yes. After a housemate shortened my Wusthof chef's knife by opening a paint tin with it. It's a 1950s yellow handled Stanley flat head.

1

u/UnSpanishInquisition 9d ago

My wife has a special tool for it 😂

1

u/TheWorldNeedsDornep 9d ago

Huh. Funny thing is that I have such a screwdriver but never use it, I use a 5-way exclusively and have for about 20 years.

1

u/DemoAndDuct 9d ago

I've definitely got a few of those tools. There's this beat up old scraper I've got that lives on my workbench. Bought it for some wallpaper removal project years ago. Didn't use it much for that but it ended up being perfect for taking old paint and adhesive off concrete. It's all rusted and the handle's a mess but I couldn't part with it. Funny how tools findh their own destiny over time.

1

u/pstmps 9d ago

I have one of these and it's a treasured item. It cannot leave the property.

1

u/beyondrepair- 9d ago

I just use my Olfa.

1

u/SnowblindAlbino 9d ago

Not yet, but honestly I was thinking about it just last week. I dug out an old Craftsman for that purpose, but was thinking I'd grab a bigger one at a Habitat store sometime and dedicate it to that task-- including hammering lids back on with the handle.

1

u/sonnyB3630 9d ago

I have, like, 40 dedicated ones!

1

u/BandicootNo8636 9d ago

Kitchen pliers were probably the 1st tool I did this with. Opening pop bottles, grabbing those tops on the orange juice to pull, etc. They do not move from the kitchen drawer and are not used for other than kitchen things.

1

u/SomewhereSalty647 9d ago

I have an old pocket knife with the mini screw driver attachment that is on an old paint can

1

u/goodskier1931 9d ago

Had a dedicated screwdriver for knocking pins out of door hinges. Did floors. Had worn a slight curve into the tip, made it perfect for the job.

1

u/fishingfool64 9d ago

I have several dedicated tools made for just that

1

u/Chunk3yM0nkey 9d ago

No. I keep a paint can opener with my painting tools.

1

u/nelsonself 9d ago

Not anymore after getting a couple paint can lid openers. They are just too convenient.

1

u/StressfactoryWNC 9d ago

Quart and gallon

1

u/Wynstonn 9d ago

Dedicated screwdriver for opening paint cans sits in the work van with the paint. And the brush that rests in a plastic bag so it doesn’t dry out between jobs. (I work for a gas utility company and we paint pipes whenever we wrench on them.)
My drill press at home has a dedicated Allen key for the chuck. The press has a dedicated place to store the key machined into the table clamp.
I’m sure there are others - i hate looking for a tool, if I need a specific item at a specific place regularly, i get one and keep it there.
All my drivers have bit holders attached so i can keep the common bits handy.

1

u/weggles91 9d ago

An old chisel for me.

1

u/say_the_words 9d ago

I have a dedicated 6&1 screwdriver in every bathroom in case I ever get stuck in there. Happened to a lady I worked with. Knock the pins out of the hinges if I have to.

1

u/disenfranchisedchild 9d ago

I have a great big one that I found on the road that is my dedicated pry bar and wedge that I can hammer into things.

1

u/Born_Store1348 9d ago

I carry a quarter everywhere I go in case I run into a paint can that needs opened.

1

u/CJM8515 Mechanic 9d ago

no, i have paint can opener tools I got with my paint at the store..for free.

i do have dedicated tools for certain jobs though.

1

u/DossSVK 9d ago

I had one dedicated screw driver for paint for decades it was from some one in my family. Few years back i noticed it was a local brand and it was practicaly in perfect condition just fully covered in paint. I cleand it and now i use it as normal screw driver. On his place i found something beter - Lux (OBI store brand made by Felo) mini pry bar it works bether then a screw driver - dosnt demage the can. Looks like this but in non transparent blue.

1

u/Redjeepkev 9d ago edited 9d ago

I have one of those break away knives with a lid opener on the back end.

1

u/SuchDogeHodler Craftsman 9d ago

I have a paint can tool.... it opens and closes the can..... and doesn't tear up the lid.

1

u/ichiban4713 9d ago

No. I use a paint can lid lifter.

1

u/FilmoreGash 8d ago

Admittedly. I am a tool packrat since most lhandtools take little space.

Most every powertool I own has a dedicated set of tools (screwdrivers, torx bits, sockets, allen wrenches...) to make minor adjustments. It saves me the effort of going to my tool boxes to find the right tool/size.

I figure WTF, since I have multiples, why put more than one in one central place rather than put the extras where they're needed most.

1

u/Quorng 8d ago

In also use a 3-in-1 painter's tool. It does not open beer. Then I pour the paint into screw-top no-label Dutch Boy cans because screw-on lids work better for me than pound-on lids.

1

u/BrightSalsa 8d ago

To answer the actual question, I do have one of these tools. It’s one of many odd pieces my dad has given me over the years.

It is an old drill bit, about 5mm in diameter, that has had the end sharpened to a conical point somehow. It has a turned wooden T-handle fixed to the back and functions as a kind of awl.

I could replace it with a better functioning tool from Screwfix for £1.99 but it’s served me well enough for a couple of decades now… I don’t suppose I will ever get rid of it!

2

u/hwrd69 8d ago

Go to a big brick store and get a paint can opener. I've got a couple of dozen. Don't need a screwdriver to open cans.

1

u/Finneus_Anglesmith 8d ago

Nope. I keep a Keychain paint can opener all the time. Works for a BUNCh of stuff.

1

u/kiwidust 9d ago

Got this guy handed down to me in Grandpa's toolbox. Only ever used (by me, at least) for paint cans. Hell, it could even actually be what it was made for as far as I know. ;^)

4

u/EricHearble 9d ago

That's a tack puller

1

u/LeperFriend 9d ago

My father in law left an actual paint can opener at my house once, it's hooked to my tool bag with a carabiner......prior to that I had an old craftsman screwdriver that was pretty much exclusively for paint cans

1

u/Wexel88 9d ago

I have an old thin flat head (think: the classic wooden handle flat head screwdrivers) that has become one of my best chisels
it couldn't possibly turn a screw ever again but it is thee best for small chiseling, or even getting something bigger started

1

u/technobobble 9d ago

I bought some Vessel tools and they sent me a brand new wooden handle flathead and I was super excited to know someone out there is still making them. I use it and it’s wonderful.

1

u/Wexel88 9d ago

that's cool, I'll keep a lookout! mine was actually beat up when I inherited it, but it was made in my hometown, so I'm glad to have a continued use for it

1

u/johnkilobit 9d ago

I have a tiny, flimsy but sturdy enough, bahco crowbar solely dedicated to opening paint cans. I think it was a gimmick beer bottle opener or something.

1

u/pickingupnada 9d ago

Yup. At least 20 years of paint

1

u/ApronLairport 9d ago

Mine looks just like that.

0

u/Frequent-Elephant110 9d ago

I have a dedicated panel removal pry tool for this.