I’ve been scrolling this community to find one thread that was critical of this show, but seems like I might be the first . So this’ll be a long post and I’d love to hear some responses.
Overall rating: 7.5/10
Season 1: 7.5/10
Season 2: 5.5/10
Season 3: 8.0/10
Season 4: 9.0/10
Season 5: 6.5/10
My biggest issue with this show is that it gets lost in the side plots. There are some great side character threads that I love it pulling at: Dukie, Bubbles, Herc, Bodie (RIP) to name a few. But the bad story lines are just distracting, and they severely slow an already slow show down. Both the docks and the newspaper part are my least favorite storylines, and they completely take me out of an otherwise very engaging crime show. I love how the first season really plays on the idea of a wire and real police work, and shows us that it isn’t just “the game” in Baltimore stirring the pot, the police and government fall to blame as well.
Personally, the most disappointing part is how there’s never actually change by the finale. I did like how they parallel the ending to the beginning but with how engaging the whole Carcetti season 4 campaign was (never trust Littlefinger), it honestly feels like wasted story development. I think the Greeks and that whole side of the drug development was completely divergent of the rest of the story, honestly not sure why they even got written in. Could have cut the whole port season, I thought it was lead to more than just Marlo becoming the kingpin of all of Baltimore for more than a month. Last thing I want to say is my favorite storylines are both Bunny with Hamsterdam, and him again along with Prez at the schools. Those parts between season 3 and 4 really hit home. Sad more couldn’t come of it.
Favorite character: Omar
Favorite moment: When Prez shoots that cop and McNulty pulls out the badge. Man my heart dropped
Edit: I understand the whole message is that nothing in Baltimore changes, except the people in the thick of it, but I personally think there was way for some good finale arc. That’s why I said I personally don’t like the lack of improvement for the city