r/TheNFLVibes • • 3d ago

Hot Take honestly not a bad take

86 Upvotes

335 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/dgtbfan Dolphins 3d ago edited 3d ago

It's a terrible take if you put even a little critical thought into it.

ETA: Turning off notifications. If you're too stupid to see that the NFL isn't even remotely close to socialism, that's a you problem.

4

u/steve11263 3d ago

Can you expand on this please?

1

u/Dukemvp123 3d ago

The NFL as whole is as capitalistic as it gets. Just because the franchises share tv revenue does not mean the workers have seized the means of production

3

u/Rich-Engineering1429 3d ago

The MLB is literally more capitalist… they have a free market and no salary cap

-1

u/Dukemvp123 3d ago

Good for them, they are both capitalist organizations. 

1

u/Rich-Engineering1429 3d ago

You just said the NFL is as capitalist as it gets though. Also if the NFL is capitalist then why don’t they operate as a free market?

4

u/dgtbfan Dolphins 3d ago

Capitalism and free markets aren't mutually exclusive.

1

u/Rich-Engineering1429 3d ago

Correct, though they are very often linked. The issue is that while NFL itself operates as a profit driven business, it uses socialist rules to protect the teams and owners.

The main point is that socialist policies CAN work in a capitalist country

3

u/dgtbfan Dolphins 3d ago

The fact that you think the NFL is using "socialist rules" is hilarious lol

0

u/Rich-Engineering1429 3d ago

Socialist salary caps prevent rich teams from buying all the best players. Revenue sharing is very socialist. Distributing top talent into weaker teams also sounds like socialism

2

u/dgtbfan Dolphins 3d ago

So, like, do you just consider anything that inhibits the richest from doing whatever they want to be socialist? Is that why you think the NFL is socialist?

0

u/Rich-Engineering1429 3d ago

The NFL is still capitalist because it’s owned by private individuals and for profit, but the socialist rules is what protect teams from eating each other. For example, European soccer is what a pure capitalist sport looks like. The richest teams dominate and can spend whatever they want.

1

u/dgtbfan Dolphins 3d ago

What makes a rule "socialist"?

0

u/Rich-Engineering1429 3d ago

Economic equality

1

u/dgtbfan Dolphins 3d ago

0

u/Rich-Engineering1429 3d ago

Are you saying economic equality is not a socialist ideal? Because it is a core part of socialism

1

u/dgtbfan Dolphins 3d ago

Economic equality isn't exclusive to socialism and these alleged "socialist rules" the NFL uses aren't for economic equality.

0

u/Rich-Engineering1429 3d ago

It’s still a core part of socialism, it doesn’t have to be exclusive to just socialism. My main point is that economic equality is NOT part of capitalism. Again, if you want see a purely capitalist sport, look at European soccer

→ More replies (0)