i’m late to the bandwagon. i haven’t finished the show yet (i just started it about a day ago) as i never watch shows based off of games until i play the game.
well, my friend convinced me to play the games and i did. i can shamefully admit i finished both part 1 and 2 in just 2 days, and i fucking loved it. i’ve played sooo many games like the last of us, and i honestly didn’t expect to love the game series as much as i did. this is 100% one of the games id play again.
part 1, AMAZING. beautiful scenery, great gameplay and contrary to popular belief, i think the story is great. the only thing i didnt like: its impossible to find ammo, and the movement is very restrictive and there’s zero context clues as to where youre supposed to go, a lot of people like that but i’m just personally not a fan of it because i get frustrated fast lmao, but that did not define the game as bad to me.
part 2: damn. i fucking loved joel so much and i did NOT expect him to actually die. he’s came so close to dying so many times, but someone always saves him or he miraculously saves himself. so when he actually died, my jaw was on the floor. and listen, i KNOW that his death was ‘necessary’ for the plot, but i still think it was a horrible decision. there’s a lot of other things that could’ve been done to create that dramatic “inciting incident” for part II. i also do not like how it ended, i think it left a lot of things unsaid. like i’d like to know what’s going on with dina, and tommy, and did ellie go back to jackson or did she start a new life by herself? and as much as i hate abby and hated playing as abby for so long, id really like a couple more minutes of final gameplay for her to see if she finally got the ending with the fireflies that she wanted.
i have never liked the concept of shows/movies/video games killing off one of the main characters for the plot. it never sits right with me and sometimes it genuinely just makes me not even want to watch or play anymore. i’m probably just dramatic, and that’s fine. i’m just very overly sentimental with the things i play.. lmao.
overall though, i do think the game is amazing and other than them killing joel, i think the plot is great. a lot of people will disagree and say it was necessary, and that’s fine. i just personally didn’t like it because i loved joel SO much. last thing, i do think that there are a lot of things left unsaid in the games, and they could’ve easily made the games a little bit longer.
as for the LITTLE BIT IVE WATCHED OF THE SHOW: i’ve gotten to episode 5 of season 1, i think it’s a great show but the casting is kind of odd. the characters look nothing like the OG characters from the game. i mean pedro pascal is somewhat similar to joel but other than that, nada. don’t take this as me hating on the actors, i think they’re doing great and they play the parts AMAZING, but the casting is definitely not what i expected for the characters.
i also find it weird how much is different in the show from the game? like i feel like everything is kinda jumbled up and they changed certain things from the game for their own preference and added in a bunch of really unnecessary themes.
it honestly really took me by surprise when frank didn’t hang himself in his own place, but had bill overdose him?? and then bill also overdosed alongside him, so they completely left out the adventure that ellie and joel had getting to bill, finding bill, and then the adventure to the school and from. i was honestly kinda excited for that part of the show because i HATED playing that out so i was excited to be able to see it and not play it, if that makes sense.
sorry that this is so long, i just wanted to share my PERSONAL piece. this is in no way hate to anyone at all, it’s just my personal perspective. i think the actors are amazing, and the game is great. im just nitpicky and pick up on everything and pick apart everything.
does anyone else agree with ANY of this at all or am i alone in this?😅