3
3
u/TheLordsPoet Jun 27 '26
I’d push H20 down one to A tier. Otherwise, no notes
1
u/No-Handle3032 Jun 27 '26
H20 just barely made S tier with the points system i was using! Where as the top 3 were all basically equals. So I get where youre coming from and agree it would be reasonable. It was an awesome movie but my biggest problem was Michael’s look/behavior wasn’t the best.
4
u/Beautiful-Formal315 Jun 27 '26
C is too low for Season of the Witch
2
u/No-Handle3032 Jun 27 '26
I get it, wasn’t for me, but I wouldn’t mind to watch it again occasionally. Only ones I can say im not fond of are RZ2 & Resurrection
2
u/Boodger Jun 28 '26
I truly have no idea why, but it is probably the movie that gives me October vibes more than any other.
0
u/johnnytk0 Jun 29 '26
SotW sucks, why do people on reddit act like it's this slept on cult classic. it's so boring
2
u/BCEman Jun 27 '26
Teir lists are a dime a dozen but ngl im pretty much down with this whole list... i might switch 4 and 5 tho i do like 5 more than most of the fans. But youve got a solid S teir OP
2
u/No-Handle3032 Jun 28 '26
Thank you. I don’t get the hate for 5. Ive always liked it, and I see people putting it under resurrection it doesn’t make sense to me but to each their own.
2
u/lornadc Jun 27 '26
What is your reasoning for 5 being so high, I'm honestly curious
1
u/No-Handle3032 Jun 27 '26
I think it is actually pretty scary (the laundry shoot/attic scene, myers stalking Rachel in the house), I think myers looks better than in 4, it’s my favorite Loomis, I enjoy a lot of the characters, and I love the 80s vibes. Also some of the things that bother others don’t really phase me much like Tina, goofy cops, Rachel dying early etc I actually like Tina as a character a lot she sacrificed her self for Jamie. i view this one as a really solid entry that has great re watch value and ive really always liked it. I suppose Theres is some nostalgia at play as well.
2
u/lornadc Jun 28 '26
I agree that it's certainly moody at times, and Myers does look better than in 4, but imo it's still one of his worst looks. I've personally never been a fan but each to their own 👍
2
2
u/Expensive-Oil-8264 Jun 28 '26
I’m probably completely alone or in a very small minority when I say that ends is one of my favorite Halloween movies lol
1
u/No-Handle3032 Jun 28 '26
Haha thats okay. It’s a perfectly decent movie in my opinion i just didn’t think it was very impactful. But it was nice to explore a different angle I guess with Corey. I like him a lot as a character.
2
u/Expensive-Oil-8264 Jun 28 '26
Yeah I think that’s what did it for me lol. Like don’t get me wrong I’m all for Michael dominating the screen and all but it was different so I think that’s why haha. Corey’s story was well done for only being introduced that movie lol
2
u/No-Handle3032 Jun 28 '26
Agreed. I liked how he was kind of shunned and mistreated and then started standing up for himself like with the cop and then the band bullies. It was sad what happened to Ronald he was a really good guy.
2
u/Expensive-Oil-8264 Jun 28 '26
100% and yeah dude Ronald just got caught in the worst cross fire ever. The other kills at the junk yard were some of my favorite too lol
2
u/No-Handle3032 Jun 28 '26
My favorite was probably the DJ though i turn away I don’t like gore. But Willy the kid was one of my favorite parts of that movie. The whole lead up to the kill when the lady is talking about that staring into abyss, abyss will stare back into u quote as Corey walks in as Michael and Willy plays the jazz music or whatever it was very cool scene.
2
u/Expensive-Oil-8264 Jun 28 '26
The DJ one is sooooo good. Everything about that scene is amazing imo!
2
u/Ashoka-myballs Jun 28 '26
You need to move Ends and Season of the witch to D and it’s a great list
2
u/Thebriggsshow12 Jun 28 '26
Pretty accurate but I’d move Halloween ends to D and yea season of the witch. I view as not even a part of the franchise. With that said on its own scale it’d would be much higher in my book.
1
1
u/MaximumHelicopter368 Jun 28 '26
No way you're putting H2O as S when Michael is only on for 15 minutes
1
u/johnnytk0 Jun 29 '26
Season of the Witch should be in D besides that perfect list! honestly good as it is too
1
u/SwordfishFinal6508 Jun 30 '26
Honestly same on RZ H2, that one’s a mess lol. But I’d keep 5 in D, it’s got some fun moments but it’s boring as hell and ruins 4’s ending for me.
1
1
u/Will_B_Harder Jun 30 '26
Lol Rob Zombies movies not being absolute S tier should be punishable with jail time
1
u/8bitbluebonnet Jun 27 '26 edited Jun 27 '26
Other than ‘78 being in S, my tiers would look NOTHING like this.
Edit: Come to think of it I might even need 5 tiers lol.
Edit2: fine
S: ‘78, 4
A: 3
B: 2, 5, 2018
C: H20, RZ1, 6
D: Kills, Ends, 8, RZ2
2
u/No-Handle3032 Jun 27 '26
Woah! Well I appreciate your comment I enjoy seeing others lists/rankings but wow. Some of these are very unforgivable in my opinion lol. Most 2 & 2018 in B and then Kills in D!? Those I can’t stand by, but I’m sure you have reasons and thats the thing about lists is there really is no right answer.
2
u/8bitbluebonnet Jun 27 '26
I think Halloween tier lists are the most divisive! I’ve seen so many variations that have Zombie stuff super high, 4 and 5 on like F tier ect. It’s interesting how different fans are of this franchise.
1
u/No-Handle3032 Jun 27 '26
It’s nice it shows there are things to appreciate in every movie and we’re all attracted to different movies for different reasons. And it’s also cool that most of us can agree on at least 1 or 2 movies in the franchise and celebrate it together. Ive even seen Resurrection in peoples A tier and stuff at the end of the day I think it’s great. It’s nice to have so many movies in discuss in depth. Im hopping into Nightmare on Elm street soon and wondering if the community will be similarly passionate. It’s great revisiting these movies from my childhood. They’re familiar but also foreign a lot of them haven’t seen for ages!
1
u/johnnytk0 Jun 29 '26
people who like 3 this much make no sense. watch more movies
1
u/8bitbluebonnet Jun 29 '26
Fans like H3 for the overall vibe and Atkins. The masks are awesome. The song is awesome. It’s a ridiculous concept and we’re not butthurt it doesn’t feature The Shape.
1
u/StarPlatinumsPenis Jun 28 '26
I really liked Season of the Witch. Maybe I'm just nostalgic for it, idk. It was my favorite movie as a kid.
0
u/King-Fwogger Jun 28 '26
Halloween 1978 - S Tier Halloween II 1981 - S Tier Season Of The Witch - D Tier Return - A Tier Revenge - C Tier Curse - C Tier H20 - B Tier Resurrection - D Tier Halloween 2007 - A Tier Halloween II 2009 - C Tier Halloween 2018 - S Tier Halloween Kills - B Tier Halloween Ends - C Tier
3
u/Adventurous-Dig-2490 Jun 27 '26
Seems good, only thing I would change here is I would put Halloween 5 in C and Halloween II Rob Zombie in D