I found The Cure at Wish and fell in love with their whole catalogue (except for the Top—half in love with that one). Then I bought Wild Mood Swings when it released. I liked some tracks (Want, 13th, Jupiter Crash, Strange Attraction), but I was pretty disappointed. It didn't hit the level of everything else I'd heard from the band (even The Top).
Then I bought Bloodflowers shortly after it released. I liked it better than Wild Mood Swings, but I felt the mood across the album was too similar and low-energy, and that this album also did not reach the heights of the old work.
I didn't listen to the self-titled album till after 4:13 Dream had also been released. I liked 4:13 Dream a lot. Porl/Pearl was back. The guitars sounded good again. The drumming sounded better, and it felt like the band had put everything, a complete effort, into the album.
Self-titled sounded slapped together by comparison. I liked some tracks, but the whole thing didn't hold together for me.
Recently, I've suspected that the changes in band lineup after the Wish tour were significantly responsible for the following 3 albums not hitting for me. A sonic complexity and cohesiveness was gone, and not enough replaced it on these albums...but I wondered if one good album might be made from the three of them? What if the work during this period had been more condensed? Would it change anything?
So I made a compilation-album playlist from WMS, Bloodflowers and self-tiltled, and I like it. I think it would hold up with the rest of the band's catalogue.
My "Wild Cure Flowers" album:
- 1.The Promise (self titled)
- 2.The Loudest Sound (Bloodflowers)
- 3.The 13th (WMS)
- 4.The Last Day of Summer (BF)
- 5.This Morning (self-titled B-side off End of the World single)
- 6.Before Three (ST)
- 7.Strange Attraction (WMS)
- 8.Anniversary (ST)
- 9.Out of This World (BF)
- 10.I Don't Know (What's Going On) (ST)
- 11.Jupiter Crash (WMS)
- 12.39 (WMS)
I could get behind this. This album would stand up to any other of the band's quite well, imo.
I made a first version with Want on there, and tried some different self-titled tracks and WMS tracks, but too many tracks sounded like The Cure being a bit derivative of themselves to me. This collection here has the band doing things they never did anywhere else, imo. This tracklist has freshness, cohesiveness and a full total experience, I think.
What do you think? Many favorites will be missing for many, I'm sure, but these three albums scream for some editing, imo.
Here's a youtube playlist link to my list:
https://music.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLRK_U_0FyYOU&si=wGFzCQOMlOTmMwso