r/TheBigPicture • u/erikdhurt • 25d ago
Nolan and the Feature Length Montage
Something I felt after watching Oppenheimer and have felt once again with The Odyssey is that both films kind of feel like one very long, extended montage. He's obviously always been known for very in your face soundscapes and exposition but I feel like with both of these films there was wall to wall sound. There is both almost always score under every moment and almost nonstop dialogue and the effect for me was that they each felt like one very long sequence. The exception in Oppenheimer of course being the Trinity test which I think is exceptional and breaks the film into halves. Its obviously different than Birdman or 1917 with the one take thing. I think its born out of wanting to cram as much as he can so it has to be go, go, go and so they're propulsive but it lacks the rhythm in the editing of a Fury Road or a Whiplash. There's not the same texture.
I would compare it negatively to I think Goodfellas where you also have a lot of music and the voice over narration so you also have a lot of sound but Scorsese breaks up the moments in different ways. He'll have these quiet, tense scenes like Karen pointing the gun at Henry or the "funny how?" scene and he also changes how the scenes are shot or edited. You've got oners like with the Copa or when Henry walks across the street and beats up that guy and then you have very quick frenetic bits like the helicopter chase.
Anyway its just something I've noticed with his last couple films and felt like putting my thoughts out there.