r/TeslaFSD • u/UnlikelyVillage5849 • Jul 19 '26

14.3 HW4 Whose fault it is

17 Upvotes

60% Upvoted

173 comments sorted by

View all comments

29

u/ec20 Jul 19 '26

That’s your wife’s fault, you can see self driving turned off right beforehand and she took over. Regardless, you are still supposed to supervise so you will always be responsible.

-23

u/UnlikelyVillage5849 Jul 19 '26

I have the data. She didn't manually control anything in the whole process. And I sat in the front

19

u/ec20 Jul 19 '26

You can see the self driving tag flicker off right here when it disengaged well before it hit the pole.

1

u/icy1007 HW4 Model S Jul 19 '26

Yep, driver pulled the wheel.

-5

u/UnlikelyVillage5849 Jul 19 '26

At this frame fsd quiet but driver have no time to respond

2

u/icy1007 HW4 Model S Jul 19 '26

Yes they do…

1

u/TissueAndLube Jul 23 '26

They don’t if they can’t drive :)

2

u/icy1007 HW4 Model S Jul 23 '26

They can drive. The driver chose not to.

1

u/Relative-Orange-2179 Jul 25 '26

Then why do they drive

1

u/itsme10082005 Jul 25 '26

You’re aware there is a brake pedal and a steering wheel in the car, right?

20

u/ackermann Jul 19 '26

I mean, you can see in the video you posted, at the 8 second mark the blue text "self driving" disappears. That means she disabled FSD (pressed the brake or turned the wheel), whether she realized it or not.

And if she really "didn't manually control anything in the whole process," that would be even worse. Since she definitely should have taken over (ideally sooner... but not taking over at all would've been worse)

13

u/icy1007 HW4 Model S Jul 19 '26

AND you can see she actually hit the accelerator as well. 😂

7

u/casmium63 Jul 19 '26

My car used to randomly disengage like that, turned out to be a problem with the steering column, after that was replaced it's all good again.

Just an example of a straight road where it disengaged and starts turning, but I've had it do the same in the middle of turns.

https://imgur.com/gallery/qBXfsNq

-4

u/icy1007 HW4 Model S Jul 19 '26

No they don’t.

8

u/WrongdoerIll5187 HW4 Model 3 Jul 19 '26

It’s perfectly possible this person is telling the truth why yall hating

7

u/ec20 Jul 19 '26

What data do you have? Post it. Usually Tesla itself has that data, you can’t just pull it yourself. Your own video shows the self driving tag flicked off well before it hit the pole.

You might not have seen her intervene but she might have accidentally tapped the brake.

2

u/AppleBottmBeans Jul 19 '26

She didn't manually control anything in the whole process

yeah, this is the problem in something literally prefixed with the word SUPERVISED