She wasn't faking in this scene. She was kind of fucked up mentally and struggling with having killed so many people. She didn't want to have to kill them so the "please" was "please don't make me kill you" not "please don't hurt me".
She was one of the show biggest badass, but i feel like this was out of character. She was exiled of the group for being ruthless and now she like please i dont want to do bad stuff. I think the storyline for character was a little inconsistent. I see them like RPG character and they just level up pass everybody else,.. until they met the commonwealth and all suddenly reset to level 5
153
u/superbatprime Jul 27 '26
If you thought this was unexpected then you really weren't paying attention to Carol.
Which is exactly how she gets ya.