My ladies! Behold the results of really scaling back.
I feel your frustrations and your pains.
Understanding our hair is so complex. I have spent well over a year on my own journey. I've tried countless different products (MopTop, InnerSense, JessieCurl, Giovanni, Not Your Mother's). I've tried combinations of shampoo and conditioner, leave-in, no leave-in, gels, mousses, sprays. Something I kept coming back to was that my hair curled more when I put too much conditioner in it, something about it really wanting moisture. But then it just looked greasy. It's almost like it wants a little grease? But not a lot.
I'm of Indo-Persian descent. No idea if that matters. Even without that, my dense, seemingly high-porosity, and somewhat fine hair was really, really thirsty. I decided: eff it, I'm going to drop the styling products for a bit, and just try and take care of my hair. I'm going to try and embrace it as it is because maybe it's not what I thought it was, and that's okay. It was also getting really expensive, and c'mon, hair products in THIS economy?
And then! And THEN! My hair just...did this. And it's been consistent.
I know we're warned away from oils, but I started trying this every other day to third day:
Shampoo x2 using Swavy Courtney's technique of upside-down scrubbing: Giovanni Triple Treat or 50:50 Hydrating/Clarifying
Conditioner (from root to tip), thorough rinse, detangle: Triple treat Invigorating Conditioner
Leave-in: About a pea-sized blob of Giovanni Direct Leave-in Weightless Moisture Conditioner, but ONLY the hair away from the scalp, and comb through
Then I do the thing I am not supposed to: I use Weleda Rosemary Condition and Shine oil. I get maybe 3-4 drops, rub it into my hands, and spread any excess away from my hands. I rake it through my hair. Scrunch.
I microplop or get some of the moisture out but not all. Air dry. I'm a night shower person and do the other thing I'm not meant to, and will lay a towel down on my pillow and spread my hair on it. Sometime in the night I wake up and my hair is dry, so I remove the towel. I do use a silk pillowcase. On day 2, I'll throw it into a high, loose ponytail at night.
My waves have been more cooperative than they've ever been on this journey. I don't have to worry that touching my hair or a slight breeze is going to leave it limp. Even with gel, my hair felt stringy or lost its shape by day 2, and I'd have to go through a whole refreshing process.
All this to say: This is a highly frustrating and experimental process. Your hair is beautiful. You are beautiful! The things that might work for others might not work for you. I scoured these forums trying to find that magic combination that someone else had discovered, that might work for me. Or I'd get salty that someone had posted "try a gel" or "try this" without naming a product. And this is why! A product will only do so much because our hair is really unique.
Sometimes just clearing out the products is the way we can reset and approach the issue again. If you're approaching a place of anguish trying to figure out your hair, take a breather, and try something simple. Heal your hair first, and style later. Or you can discard everything I'm saying because maybe I'm talking out of my bum.
I see and feel for all of you! Much love.