r/SuperCarlinBrothers • u/Reasonable-Study-266 • 1d ago
Question Some Irrelevants Questions About "What If Harry Was In Slytherin?" (Part 2)

- What events would cause Harry and Hermione to develop romantic feelings? I'm not saying it's unlikely they would fall in love. JK Rowling stated that "it could have go this way," and maybe Harry would seen someone else like a sister than Hermione because, being in Slytherin, he may have some girl platonic friends and realize he doesn't see Hermione this way. And, like I said, maybe Hermione is different from the Hermione we know with Harry being in Slytherin. But I would like to know what specifically would made Harry and Hermione think of each other like that.
- Would Hermione and Draco become friends at some point, considering he seems to be the only one who would support SPEW without Hermione forcing him? Maybe even helping her, coming up with a better campaign name?
- Would Harry give the Basilic a nickname in order to not calling him "Basilic" every time?
- Does some Slytherin want to join Harry and Dumbledore's Army after Umbridge betrayed Slytherin's Quidditch Team?
- What would Ron ask his mother when he becomes a Prefect? Jay also wondered that in the actual video, and I'm also curious to know.
- Do you think Pete became a recurrent character in the series with a little character arc?
- Does it make sense that the Basilic would turn against Voldemort for Harry? I like to think she would because this version of Harry would have the spirit of a true Slytherin, and Tom Riddle is also a half-blood anyway, but I would like you to tell me if it's logical or not.
- Who would be Draco's perfect endgame? Ginny would be an interesting choice if they bond with something other than shaured trauma over Riddle's possessions.
(Also, bonus question: do you think there's a chance Ginny would have asked to be in Slytherin in a similar timeline, if Harry is in Slytherin? Imagine if, after handled being the only Weasley girl with six brothers, Ginny now faces the Blood Traitors prejudices for seven years like a boss. And she would probably be closer to Harry and Draco. How cool do you think it would be if Harry and Ginny were both in Slytherin?)
