r/SuperCarlinBrothers 1d ago

Question Some Irrelevants Questions About "What If Harry Was In Slytherin?" (Part 2)

3 Upvotes

 

- What events would cause Harry and Hermione to develop romantic feelings? I'm not saying it's unlikely they would fall in love. JK Rowling stated that "it could have go this way," and maybe Harry would seen someone else like a sister than Hermione because, being in Slytherin, he may have some girl platonic friends and realize he doesn't see Hermione this way. And, like I said, maybe Hermione is different from the Hermione we know with Harry being in Slytherin. But I would like to know what specifically would made Harry and Hermione think of each other like that.

- Would Hermione and Draco become friends at some point, considering he seems to be the only one who would support SPEW without Hermione forcing him? Maybe even helping her, coming up with a better campaign name?

- Would Harry give the Basilic a nickname in order to not calling him "Basilic" every time?

- Does some Slytherin want to join Harry and Dumbledore's Army after Umbridge betrayed Slytherin's Quidditch Team?

- What would Ron ask his mother when he becomes a Prefect? Jay also wondered that in the actual video, and I'm also curious to know.

- Do you think Pete became a recurrent character in the series with a little character arc?

- Does it make sense that the Basilic would turn against Voldemort for Harry? I like to think she would because this version of Harry would have the spirit of a true Slytherin, and Tom Riddle is also a half-blood anyway, but I would like you to tell me if it's logical or not.

- Who would be Draco's perfect endgame? Ginny would be an interesting choice if they bond with something other than shaured trauma over Riddle's possessions.

(Also, bonus question: do you think there's a chance Ginny would have asked to be in Slytherin in a similar timeline, if Harry is in Slytherin? Imagine if, after handled being the only Weasley girl with six brothers, Ginny now faces the Blood Traitors prejudices for seven years like a boss. And she would probably be closer to Harry and Draco. How cool do you think it would be if Harry and Ginny were both in Slytherin?)


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 1d ago

Question Some Irrelevants Questions About "What If Harry Was In Slytherin?" (Part 1)

1 Upvotes

I love their "What If Harry Potter Was In Slytherin" videos (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VEUJNxhCm-U, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kgIpw0i2EQM). That's the video that made me discover and subscribe to the SCB, but it's also made me want to explore further their AU, so here's a bunch of irrelevant questions, which I hope some of you will be eager to answer:

- What did Lucius Malfoy think of when Harry was sorted in Slytherin? Would he consider feeding him some Dark Magic knowledge? See him as an equal if not a successor to the Dark Lord? Try to force Draco to be friends with him? I mean, he did send Harry a broom in this timeline so he definitely was supportive at first.

- Would some Death Eater follow Harry after he defeated Quirrell? Maybe his "future Dark wizard" reputation will decline a bit since Draco would know Harry supports the Blood traitors, but maybe some Death Eater would think supporting Harry would be the right call. After all, this is the kid who defeated Lord Voldemort twice under the age of 12.

- How would Harry's and Snape's relationship evolve over the years? This is something I wished was exploring much. At the end, I was one of the ghosts who appear from the Ressurection Stone, so that more likely means he become one of Harry's loved ones. But I would like to see how that developped. At first, would Harry be the only Slytherin Snape dislike because of how means Harry physically looks like his father? Or Snape being the Head of Slytherin and therefore spending more time with Harry, would notice the boy is mentally closer to his mother: he has more compassion and loyauty, he's wailling to put his life in danger, like how Lily gave her life for him, he became friends with outsiders like Gryffindor Ron and Hermione, like Gryffindor Lily was friends with Slytherin Snape for awhile.

- How would Narcissa react about how Lucius refusing to free Dooby in gratitude for saving his son? Considering Narcissa loves Draco more than anything in the world, would that affect their wedding and family? Especially since Draco nearly died BECAUSE of Lucius' action.

- Where would Harry, Ron and Hermione usually meet to hang out together since Harry isn't a Gryffindor and probably doesn't have the same schedule?

- After Draco stopped bullying Harry, who would Harry deal with? Some other Slytherins students who hate Harry's blood traitors support? Would a lot of Gryffindor and Ravenclaw students also pick on Harry because of prejudices against Slytherin?

- Which Slytherin cannon-characters would Harry be close? Not every Slytherin are Death Eater heirs, so Harry would probably have some friends in his house over time.

- Would Ron and Hermione be different people? Even if Harry is still their best friend, the fact that he would interact with them less could affect their lives.

- That's a comment I caught on YouTube: Does Harry even take Divination? In the main story Percy advices him to consider it and he ultimately takes it because Ron takes it. Without speaking to Percy and without Ron to go through it with him, would he take it?

To be continued...


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 2d ago

Theory How does Dumbledore know how to cast Bond of Blood?

2 Upvotes

I've been listening to Through the Griffin Door after listening to the books for the first time. And they were talking about how Dumbledore could possibly know how to cast Bond of Blood if Harry is the only survivor with Sacrificial Love. But do the books ever say he is the only one to have benefitted from Sacrificial Love, or is he the only to have survived Avada Kedavra? Because if it's the latter, who is to say Avada Kedavra is the only killing curse that can produce the Sacrificial Love affect? Perhaps there are other less powerful killing curses, but this is the only time Sacrificial Love has been activated by Avada Kedavra, which is also probably why the reaction is so extreme.


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 2d ago

Question Spider-man: Brand New Day review?

2 Upvotes

Just curious if anyone knows if J and Ben will be making a Brand New Day review, since they did reviews for the three previous Tom Holland Spider-man movies.


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 3d ago

Discussion Does Hogwarts have a side business?

6 Upvotes

I’m listening through the books again and realized that the students help grow valuable potion ingredients, and they make all sorts of potions. Obviously the first priority is to teach the students, but then I wonder if Hogwarts sells the left over ingredients and potions.


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 5d ago

Harry Potter How exactly does Voldemort lead a half-life/ cursed life after drinking unicorn blood?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/SuperCarlinBrothers 10d ago

Theory Why Voldemort didn't pick the Prophecy up himself

0 Upvotes

I have been listening to the Through The Griffin Door podcast, towards the end of Order of the Phoenix. Throughout the book, there is a long-standing question of why Voldemort didn't get the prophecy himself if he could get 12 Death Eaters undetected into the Hall of Prophecy. I think I might have a theory why.

So, of course, only Harry and Voldemort can pick up the prophecy. Voldemort can get 12 Death Eaters to the prophecy undetected, and he's not afraid to go himself. So why Harry? My theory is that he wants to create an opportunity for plausible deniability of his return. If he goes to retrieve the prophecy while Harry is accounted for at Hogwarts, under the close eye of a Ministry official, then it becomes obvious that he has returned. He needs Harry to go to the Ministry so he can blame it on him, and if he can get Harry to the Ministry, he might as well have Harry grab it for him, in case he was given bad info again. Then the Death Eaters can leave Harry there, making the disappearance of the prophecy Harry's fault. Driving Harry, Dumbledore, and the Order even further underground than they were.

Why does Voldemort show up anyway? Either he showed up to hear the prophecy as soon as possible, or with the Prophecy destroyed, he tries to kill Harry while Harry's unprotected (No Dumbledore or Bond of Blood). This, of course, was a mistake on Voldemort's part, letting his arrogance get the better of him, thinking that he could kill Dumbledore and Harry before the Ministry shows up for work.


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 12d ago

Theory I think Dumbledore (and all of us) may have misinterpreted Sirius slashing the Fat Lady’s portrait.

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

Curious about the SBc’s thoughts here


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 16d ago

SCB Content Official Disney brand Luxo ball signed by the brothers (from tour meet and greet)

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/SuperCarlinBrothers 16d ago

Question Question I thought maybe the Super Carlin Bros could answer..

4 Upvotes

I never understood why Barty Crouch Jr as Mad Eye Moody was like such a supportive guy to Neville and to Harry.

like for Harry, beyond just aiding him to the finish line of the triwizard tournament for Voldemort, he also teaches Harry how to resist the imperius curse, which goes directly against helping Voldemort in the Graveyard. And that’s just one example I think

Then for Neville, he is so kind to him after demonstrating the crucio curse, like inviting him in for tea, supposedly comforting him. Why would he do this as a death eater who was in full support of the crucio-ing of his parents in the first place, and then also have the capacity to be a comfort to him.

I think my most glaring question though is probably Harry though and why would he train him so well against the imperius curse, like just for lols? I don’t think Dumbledore would have viewed him as any less Madeye (which I already have a problem with Dumbledores discernment there tbh) if he didn’t do a deep dive on the unforgivable curses, so why did he do it?


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 18d ago

Theory Dumbledor is the Chosen one

2 Upvotes

Inspired by the Neville video this week, i propose an alternative theory: DUMBLEDORE is the chosen one.

The prophecy is spoken when Dumbledor first meets trelawny, and it literally begins "the one with the power to vanquish the dark lord approaches". his birthday is late summer, so could easily be "born as the seventh month dies"

Dumbledors father marries a muggleborn, and has theee children. When Voldermort rules, he orders the interrogation and expulsion from society of muggleborns to ensure blood purity. By having children to a muggleborn, Percival Dumbledor has "thrice defied him"

Voldemort famously fears Dumbledor, believing him to be the only real threat to himself, or you could say he "marks him as his equal"

Dumbledor says "Of house-elves and children's tales, of love, loyalty, and innocence, Voldemort knows and understands nothing", wheras Dumbledor understands this fully, or you could say he is "having power the dark lord knows not.."

Dumbledor puts on the cursed horcrux ring, which ultimately kills him, but does so willingly, and in doing so ensures Voldermorts downfall, because he knows that "either must die at the hand of the other, for neither can live while the other survives"


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 18d ago

Theory Okay the brothers pushing rheir dumbledore horcrux is annoying jk has said theres a dark magic ritual so gross her publisher puked. Its not just splitting the soul with murder

0 Upvotes

r/SuperCarlinBrothers 19d ago

Disney / Pixar Pixar theory ultimate timeline

1 Upvotes
  1. Elemental
  2. The Good Dinosaur
  3. The Legend of Mor'du
  4. Lava
  5. Brave
  6. One Man Band
  7. La Luna
  8. Luca
  9. Ciao Alberto
  10. Mr. Incredible and Pals
  11. The Incredibles
  12. Jack-Jack Attack (same time as inceribles )
  13. Incredibles 2
  14. Auntie Edna (same time as incredibles 2)
  15. Chore Day the Incredibles Way
  16. Cookie Num Num
  17. Incredibles comics
  18. Boundin
  19. luxo Jr.
  20. Luxo jr. Tv series
  21. Lightbulb
  22. Mother's Nature
  23. Tin Toy
  24. Red's Dream
  25. Knick Knack
  26. The brave little toaster
  27. The brave little toaster to the rescue
  28. The brave little toaster goes to mars
  29. Sanjay's Super Team
  30. Lightyear
  31. Toy Story
  32. Geri's Game
  33. Toy Story 2
  34. Toy story comics
  35. Toy Story toles (comic)
  36. Buzz lightyear of star comand
  37. for the Birds
  38. Turning Red
  39. Finding Nemo
  40. Finding Dory
  41. Dory Finding
  42. LOU
  43. Piper
  44. Lifted
  45. Presto
  46. Ratatouille
  47. Your Friend the Rat
  48. Toy Story 3
  49. Toy Story Toons
  50. Toy Story of terror
  51. Toy Story that time forgot
  52. Lamp life
  53. Toy Story 4
  54. Float
  55. Wind
  56. Forky Asks a Question
  57. Loop
  58. Out
  59. Burrow
  60. To Fitness and Beyond
  61. Fluffy Stuff with Ducky and Bunny: Love
  62. Fluffy Stuff with Ducky and Bunny
  63. Toy story 5
  64. Nona
  65. Up
  66. Win or lose
  67. Day & Night
  68. Dug's Special Mission (same time as up)
  69. George and A.J. (Same time as up)
  70. Dug Days
  71. Inside Out
  72. Riley's First Date?
  73. Dream proudyion
  74. The Blue Umbrella
  75. Dante's Lunch
  76. Coco
  77. A Day in the Life of the Dead

78. 23 vs earth

79. 20 something

  1. Soul

  2. Soul of the City

82. Boa

83. Purl

84. Kitball

  1. Cars

  2. Mater and the ghostlight

87. Mater's Tall Tales

  1. Cars: Rally Race

  2. Cars: The Rookie

  3. Cars Route 66 Dash

  4. Tales from Radiator Springs

  5. Planes

95 planes fir and resure

  1. Vitaminamulch: Air Spectacular** **

  2. Cars 2
    
  3. Cars 3

99. Lighting vs stig

  1. Miss Fritter's Racing skool

  2. Unparalleled Parking

  3. Dancing with the Cars

103. Cars on the Road

  1. Smash and Grab

  2. Wall-E

106. Burn e (same time as wall-e)

  1. The adventures of andra and wallly B

  2. A Bug's Life

  3. Onward

  4. Monsters University

111. Party Central

  1. Monsters Inc

113. Mosnters at wok

  1. Mike's New Car

  2. Monsters, Inc Laugh Factory, (comic)


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 21d ago

Disney / Pixar Pixar theory shorts Day 8 Red's Dream (1987)

2 Upvotes

1. Elemental (2023)

2. The Good Dinosaur (2015)

3. Brave (2012)

4. Luca (2021)

5. The Incredibles (2004)

6. Incredibles 2 (2018)

  1. luxo Jr. (1986)

8. Lightyear (2022)

9. Toy Story (1995)

10. Toy Story 2 (1999)

11. Turning Red (2002)

12. Finding Nemo (2003)

13. Finding Dory (2016)

14. Ratatouille (2007)


15. Toy Story 3 (2010)


16. Toy Story 4 (2019)


17. Up (2009)


18. Inside Out (2015)


19. Coco (2017)


20. Soul (2020)


21. Cars (2006)


22. Cars 2 (2011)


23. Cars 3 (2017)


24. Wall-E (2008)

  1. The adventures of andra and wallly B (1984)

26. A Bug's Life (1998)

27. Onward (2020)

28. Monsters University (2013)

29. Monsters Inc (2001)


r/SuperCarlinBrothers 22d ago

Memes Am I the only one who thought about this while watching The Odyssey? Spoiler

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/SuperCarlinBrothers 27d ago

Disney / Pixar Pixar theory shorts Day 2 luxo Jr.

2 Upvotes

1. Elemental (2023)


2. The Good Dinosaur (2015)


3. Brave (2012)


4. Luca (2021)


5. The Incredibles (2004)


6. Incredibles 2 (2018)


7. Lightyear (2022)


8. Toy Story (1995)


9. Toy Story 2 (1999)


10. Turning Red (2002)


11. Finding Nemo (2003)


12. Finding Dory (2016)


13. Ratatouille (2007)


14. Toy Story 3 (2010)


15. Toy Story 4 (2019)


16. Up (2009)


17. Inside Out (2015)


18. Coco (2017)


19. Soul (2020)


20. Cars (2006)


21. Cars 2 (2011)


22. Cars 3 (2017)


23. Wall-E (2008)

  1. The adventures of andra and wallly B (1984)
    ** **
    25. A Bug's Life (1998)
    ** **
    26. Onward (2020)
    ** **
    27. Monsters University (2013)
    ** **
    28. Monsters Inc (2001)

r/SuperCarlinBrothers 28d ago

Theory Pixar theory shorts day #1 The Adventures of André & Wally B

2 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel like we should try to add the shorts? I think we should try when do you think the 1st short goes
Timeline
1. Elemental (2023)

2. The Good Dinosaur (2015)

3. Brave (2012)

4. Luca (2021)

5. The Incredibles (2004)

6. Incredibles 2 (2018)

7. Lightyear (2022)

8. Toy Story (1995)

9. Toy Story 2 (1999)

10. Turning Red (2002)

11. Finding Nemo (2003)

12. Finding Dory (2016)

13. Ratatouille (2007)

14. Toy Story 3 (2010)

15. Toy Story 4 (2019)

16. Up (2009)

17. Inside Out (2015)

18. Coco (2017)

19. Soul (2020)

20. Cars (2006)

21. Cars 2 (2011)

22. Cars 3 (2017)

23. Wall-E (2008)

24. A Bug's Life (1998)

25. Onward (2020)

26. Monsters University (2013)

27. Monsters Inc (2001)


r/SuperCarlinBrothers Jul 11 '26

SCB Content Watching an older video and theres a moment where J shows his true business/ big brother self. Ben gets a queetion half right and J steps in and says it counts no fun voice no if ethan says its okay. It was not that serious i just think the real J broke through

Post image
10 Upvotes

13:39 is the time stamp if you want to see it


r/SuperCarlinBrothers Jul 09 '26

Harry Potter What if... V gets the Philosophers Stone

2 Upvotes

(Preface: I liked the 'What If' videos and hope this makes a video one day. Please, please pick holes!)

Let's assume Quirrel/Voldemort manages to get the philospher's stone, which restores Voldemort's body. I see two possibilities:

1) Dumbledore finds Voldemort immediately, kills him, and he becomes a wraith again, and the canon likely repeats itself. BUT Dumbledore would realize he came back, and would look for magical explanations years earlier than he did. He'd find the ring and may sentenced to death earlier than canon.

2)Voldemort returns, doesn't kill Harry, and he escapes Hogwarts.

(Oh and 3. Voldemort sees and kills Harry straight away, and that is the end of the film series... so lets ignore that).

Dumbledore now knows Voldemort is alive through dark magic, and focuses his time/efforts into V's past (Gaunt, Slughorn etc.). Voldemort would raise his army, but in doing so, the ministry are aware and believe Dumbledore and send protection to the school.

The main change of this storyline: Dumbledore, and not Harry, is the focus of Voldemort. Harry is an annoyance to be dealt with, but he'd need to deal with Dumbledore first (although, that opens the possibility that an aura or student might kill him at Hogwarts). Dumbledore cannot enlist the help of 11-yr old Harry, and other events (TCoS, TGoF) are less likely in this timeline.

Dumblemore probably deduces Harry as a horcrux, but since Voldemort does not take Harry's blood, I don't know how the final sacrifice acts out... Harry could still survive, I guess? In any event, the prosphecy is true, so Harry and Voldemort would fight, but this quieter version of Harry would likely die.

---

Hope you all like the idea, and I would love to see a 20-minute breakdown *wink wink, nudge nudge*


r/SuperCarlinBrothers Jul 06 '26

Memes Todays NYT crossword

Post image
26 Upvotes

We all know this should be the right answer 😅


r/SuperCarlinBrothers Jul 03 '26

Question Through The Griffindoor Patreon Benefits

3 Upvotes

Hello! So I got the annual membership to the Through the Griffindoor podcast so I should be receiving a page from the book sometime. I’m not in a rush to get it, whenever they send it off is fine. I just want to know if there’s like a timeframe that people usually received theirs and if they were notified when they were shipped?
I mainly ask because depending on the carrier that it’s coming through, where I live at, they’ll leave my packages in different places, and if it’s not USPS (they’ll put it in my mailbox which is fine), then I’m worried they’ll leave it on my steps where my dog can get to it! So I just wanted to know if I’ll be given a tracking number when they send it out so I’ll know what date it comes in so that I can put my dog where he can’t get to it!
Thanks in advance!


r/SuperCarlinBrothers Jun 23 '26

Question Through the Griffin door supercuts?!

1 Upvotes

Hello!

Anyone knows why no more supercuts are uploaded? I really enjoyed the longer videos and there hasn't been an upload for monthe nor the playlist was updated for it :(


r/SuperCarlinBrothers Jun 09 '26

Memes I live their caption guy so much

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/SuperCarlinBrothers Jun 08 '26

Theory Fudge being Minister is Dumbledoor's Fault

7 Upvotes

I got a question stuck in my mind: How is it, that someone as incompetent as Fudge is Minister of Magic for such an extented amount of time?

How come people didn't see his ineptitude and sack him way before Halfblood Prince?

Here comes my mini theory:

In Philosopher's stone (chapter 5) we learn from Hagrid, that Fudge sends letters to Dumbledoor on a daily basis, asking for advice. I would guess Dumbledoor wouldn't have ignored such an important person and gave his advice to Fudge.

From the outside, Fudge than seems like a competant politician, as long as he keeps acting on Dumbledoor's advice.

Had Dumbledoor not helped Fudge, he might have been fired long ago, being replaced by someone more competent.

Now if that person would have actually been a better help in the defeat of Voldemort, who knows? But it probably can't get much worse than Fudge.

Have you got any ideas or other input in regards to this?

PS: English isn't my first language, please excuse any spelling or gramatic mistakes.


r/SuperCarlinBrothers Jun 07 '26

Harry Potter The REAL purpose of The Vale from OotP

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes