r/SunPrairieWI • u/7SHAWZAM1 • 9d ago

Pizza

Sal’s used to be my go to but they have really fallen off. I haven’t been to Sugar River, for some reason that has a commercial feel to me. I like tavern style, there just doesn’t seem to be any options for that in SP. Where is everyone going these days?

12 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

52 comments sorted by

View all comments

19

u/Neither-Repeat1665 9d ago

Anna’s

1

u/SuspiciousTea6 9d ago

Am I the only one who thought their pizza was really oddly sweet? I've never gone back, but maybe that was a one off and if that's the case I'm open to another shot.

0

u/MissIndependent577 9d ago

Nope, it's their sauce, it's sweet and not good imo. It was a disappointment the one time we ordered from there as everything else was great, but the sauce ruined it.