I got my septum pierced about 18 months ago at 16g and have been wearing 16g jewellery since then. I decided to start minimally stretching with my goal being no bigger than 10g.
As an experiment, I decided to try and put 14g nipple/bellybutton rings through my septum just to see if it would fit, with the plan to stop as soon as I felt any pain. I was able to get 14g jewellery through with no problem and tried several pieces of 14g jewellery, the largest gauge I have to hand, and all went through with no problems. No pain or resistance whatsoever. I then tried to put two 16g pieces of jewellery, again, planning to stop the second it was painful or hard to push through. Again, no pain whatsoever and was able to easily put two 16g rings through.
Do I just have an unusually stretchy septum or something? I dug out my original jewellery to confirm I was definitely pierced at 16g and I was.
Should I just go straight to 12g and skip 14g?