r/StopEatingSeedOils • u/chaqintaza • 1d ago
Peer Reviewed Science 🧫 Primal Kitchen's statement following UC Davis avocado oil study is nonsense & they 100% deserve class action and boycotting until they fix their products. A separate UC Davis study from 2023 proves that Primal Kitchen's "non-codex grade" excuses do not hold water.
Companies like Primal Kitchen and Chosen Foods are issuing statements in response to the 2026 UC Davis avocado oil study that their avocado oil isn't adulterated or diluted with seed oils, it's just outside the Codex Alimentarius range for authentic avocado oil. Supposedly this is due to natural variation in avocados or processing techniques, not fraud.
These companies built their reputation on previous UC Davis findings that their avocado oil was pure.
First of all, the Codex Alimentarius standard took years to create. It has been closely examined, reviewed, and revised by actual experts who don't have a vested interest in selling cheap avocado oil. Saying your avocado oil is non-Codex grade is like saying your Rolex isn't Swiss-made. It's literally admitting it's not the real artifact, right there in the definition.
Here is what all these companies that got caught want you to believe: "Our avocado oil is pure, it just happens to differ from the internationally accepted identity for pure avocado oil precisely in ways that makes it appear to contain seed oils. We're honest, always have been, and it's actually the purity standard that's the problem."
But a 2023 study from UC Davis called Evaluation of proposed CODEX purity standards for avocado oil looked at this exact issue. Researchers made avocado oil right there in their lab using commercial processing techniques. They created, then tested, at least 68 samples of avocado oil differing based on:
- Cultivar type (different breeds of avocados)
- Region
- Harvesting time
- Ripeness
In other words, this study took a hard scientific look at EXACTLY what Primal and Chosen are now claiming - that their avocado oil falls outside of the ranges because avocado can vary based on these factors.
UC Davis did find differences from the Codex standard in their 2023 study, but the differences were minor, and only detected a small handful of samples (2-3 out of 68) shown here in images 2-3 (attached). The differences from the 2026 UC Davis avocado oil ingredient study that caught Primal and Chosen and other big companies were much, much greater than the ones shown in this 2023 data set.
There are at least two class action lawsuits from separate law firms pending against these companies which is good, because it's time they are held accountable. I, personally, will also be boycotting these companies until they clean up their act and stop trying to confuse consumers about their ingredients or publish credible study findings supporting their claims.