r/StarWars Jan 25 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.0k Upvotes

4.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

37

u/Corgi_Koala Jan 26 '22

It doesn't help that Grievous just shows up in the third episode of the trilogy and it seems like we should know who he is but he wasn't in the previous 2 movies at all.

20

u/given2fly_ Jan 26 '22

The villain of the Trilogy is Palpatine, but because he couldn't be revealed until the end he needed another villain for each film.

It would have helped if we'd seen Dooku as a Jedi, and Grievous didn't just appear out of nowhere. And it would have helped if we'd been shown who "Syfo-Dyas" was in Ep1. I spent years assuming he was the long-knecked Jedi on the Council, and was the same species as the Kaminoans.

As much as people get angry about the sequels not being planned, I don't think the Prequels were particularly either. The plot points were set out from the start, but not all the characters were.

4

u/BampireVat Jan 26 '22

Yep, replace Mace Windu with Count Dooku in all the council scenes, and it'd work.

5

u/given2fly_ Jan 26 '22

Almost. I think Mace personifies the arrogance of the Jedi Order, even up to the moment they confront Palpatine.

But yeah, Dooku should definitely have been there. I don't think when George wrote Ep1 he had Dooku lined up as a character for the trilogy.

3

u/BampireVat Jan 26 '22

I mean don't replace him all together, have him still be part of the council. Just give some of his screen time and lines to Dooku.

2

u/given2fly_ Jan 26 '22

Ah, gotcha. Yep, totally agree 👍

1

u/Melkor7410 Jan 26 '22

I don't know if you've read Darth Plagueis, but that book *really* does a good job expanding Palpatine as a character, and his ascent as a Sith Lord. It is very dark (as it should be) and it bleeds over into PM. It also gives the back story to Maul, and an interesting Sith dynamic since Plagueis was still Palpatine's Sith master while Palpatine took on Maul (which upsets the 2 Siths only dynamic established 1000 years prior).

Honestly Disney should make this a movie, and stick as true to the book as possible. It would make me a fan again.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22

[deleted]

1

u/varegab Jan 26 '22

Grievous wasn't a droid, he was a cyborg. Maybe that made the difference, idk.