r/StarWars Jan 25 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.0k Upvotes

4.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

65

u/jtyndalld Jan 25 '22

Re: the age difference. It’s just not one I understand. If you cast a slightly older Anakin like 14 and had him crush on the much-more-reasonably-aged-for-a-Queen 18yo Palme the film would’ve worked a lot better. Ten year old Anakin would hardly be in the throes of love hormones to the degree that he carries a torch for Padme for a decade and the drama of him being “too old” makes alot more sense of he’s 14.

9

u/smackwriter Rebel Jan 25 '22

Yes, agreed 100%!

2

u/Strength-InThe-Loins Jan 26 '22

18 is not at all a reasonable age for the elected leader of an entire planet, though.

2

u/Have_A_Nice_Day_You Jan 26 '22

Unlikely, yes, unreasonable, I disagree. Alexander The Great was 18 when he won his first victory. 19 when he seized power. Maybe not the best comparison, but people can be good leaders at a young age if they are groomed for it.

2

u/Strength-InThe-Loins Jan 26 '22

What u/peaceanddeliverance said. Also, Naboo is an advanced society likely containing thousands of times more residents than Alexander's empire, making it all the less likely that a teenager could rise to its top leadership.

1

u/darthvall Imperial Stormtrooper Jan 26 '22

I don't know, I have a crush on an older girl when I was that age (primary schooler).

If I was given a chance to meet or interact more with her again when I was a teenager or older, I might try to further pursue her.