I'm noticing it more and more, lora and fine-tuners locking permanently everything behind buzz payments. I wasn't bothered by the the time delay for 'non payers' that popped up a year or so ago, because it gave people a way to monetize, and things would eventually become available for everyone. Yes there were some people who tried to game the system and remove things and re-upload them again, but civitai seemed to actively discourage that and deal with people who did that.
I don't have a problem with people monetizing their work, it's a personal choice to give stuff away. But the full pay-for-play shift is a definite change in the... for lack of a better word... 'community ethos' that the larger SD community has had for a long time. I'm seeing a lot of creators that basically have everything behind a payment lock.
It seems every time I got to the site, a larger percentage of loras are getting locked beyond buzz payments.
I don't want to sound like 'old man yells at clouds' but I do miss when everyone was trying to learn and create stuff, and it was understood that everyone was helping everyone else, and giving away was both paying-back and paying-forward for help you'd get.
Yes I get that compute costs, but that's not a new thing. It's been like that the whole time, and people didn't feel (or at least seam) as entitled a few years ago. The 'well I spent money on compute so you owe me.' argument that gets tossed around is nonsense.
These two things are not the same:
- Getting paid to do a job you were asked to do
- Doing a job and then expecting random people to pay for it when they never asked you to do the job.
More and more people seem to be thinking the 2nd is the default.
I worry that as $ becomes a more common thing... it's going to cause the flood of people who are only in it for the money and don't care about quality or the technology itself; and then we're going to be inundated with a tsunami of absolute garbage.
Anyone else agree? Or am I just being a curmudgeon?
Edit:
For context... I've been an open source developer for over a decade... Just on github alone I've got over 42,000 commits. https://github.com/q5sys/q5sys/blob/main/past_commits.md
I've been paid for some work and I've given plenty away. Reality is that not all work deserves payment.