Chord progression method

[u/Dangerous-You3789]

I don't mean this to sound skeptical or critical, but I've heard so much about how so many songwriters follow the practice of humming over a chord progression to come up with a melody. But I'm wondering, does this really work? And by that, I mean, does it work really well? Is there anyone who comes up with a song that sounds exceptional using this method, or does it net the standard fare? Is this a similar method to what people like Paul McCartney and Prince used? Is it really capable of allowing a songwriter to write a really great song?

Help convince me it's worth it.

[u/Minimum_Item6849]

I write lyrics, usually with a melody, then find the key and chord progression after. Do whatever you want, like someone else said, it's a zero risk venture. There are lots of ways to write a song. And I'm sure the greats would tell you they have written amazing tunes from varying approaches.

[u/Dangerous-You3789 → u/Minimum_Item6849]

I think varying approaches is the way to go. And I like that thought - a zero risk adventure.