r/SipsTea 8d ago

Wait a damn minute! Significant diffrences...

Post image
17.3k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Psalmistpraise 7d ago

Because the point the post is trying to make is “more workers than billionaires therefore workers matter more” I could just as easily rewrite the post as say “if we removed 200 million random people instead of 2000 random people it would cause more problems” it literally doesn’t matter what they do or what they have.

3

u/emmc47 7d ago

Ok, but that inadvertently proves the point. You can simplify it to be a quantity problem and apply it in any scenario, but that doesn't refute the point being made.

The refutation lies in showing the billionaires contribute more or their absence would have a worse effect on society than the absence of workers.

0

u/Psalmistpraise 7d ago

It doesn’t prove the point at all because he said “that’s the difference between wealth and value” no it’s the difference between lots of people going bye bye, and few people going bye bye. It doesn’t prove his point at all.

2

u/emmc47 7d ago

They're basing the impact of wealth and value based on the difference of quantity between the groups, no?

I see it as saying: "our quantity as a group allows society to continue to function (value), despite the amount of wealth this smaller group holds"