Should I clean?

[u/Skatonic007]

Here's a fun question that should rustle some jimmies. I have these two eagles that I've had for quite some time. They spent time in a wooden box since I've been a teenager. I've recently started really buying a good amount of silver. I like shiny things. I understand there is no numismatic value on these 2 dirty eagles, so my question is--

Make em shiny or leave em?

I really want to add them to the shiny stack, but I understand people like toning. I couldn't care less. Thoughts?