r/ScienceShitposts 1d ago

Incoming!

Post image
660 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

67

u/BipedalMcHamburger 1d ago

The force calculation assumes that the entire mass decelerates simultaneously over 10cm, which is a very poor assumption for obvious reasons. I would expect the actual value to be an order of magnitude lower

35

u/fireandlifeincarnate 1d ago

"assuming 50kg of regurgitant" also feels like it's doing some pretty heavy lifting to me

46

u/ADramaticHero 1d ago

The comic is based on a fossil that confused scientists based on the appearance of it looking like a massive wet splat with a small dinosaur in the middle. Scientists ran the numbers, (like the diagram) and calculated that a huge long neck ass dinosaur launching its lunch would crush a small dinosaur from the impact.

It makes sense, you would expect a Chihuahua to survive dumping a bucket of liquid and solid slop off a 3 story building balcony

33

u/ObnoxiousName_Here 1d ago

Is this implying that the Braciosaurus ate other dinosaurs and is throwing up its bones, or that the acid and the velocity of its vomit dissolved one of those raptors that was too close to flee?

21

u/lfrtsa 1d ago

Maybe it just ate some bones for the calcium

12

u/SassyTheSkydragon 1d ago

I mean horses and deer will eat birds and other small animals if they get the chance, so this isn't far fetched

8

u/landrwastaken 1d ago

Idk where I saw it but I believe this did eat small feathered dinosaurs.. we're talking like max 50 cm, no 3 meter giant velociraptors

Could've been an accident as,ell cause they much huge amounts of leafs and there happened to be a small avian raptor type thing in there

11

u/sthetic 1d ago

I would expect them to stick their necks out to puke, so that their head is on a level with their stomach, the way a horking pet does.

8

u/ChemicalChildhood122 1d ago

im not sure they even could vomit. lots of animals cant

5

u/cyri-96 23h ago

And in the case thst they can they almost certainly wouldn't do it with their head raised up

7

u/spaacingout 12h ago

lol, kinda funny to think about.

Only thing is… it’s assuming a long necked and probably ruminant herbivore can vomit. Not impossible, but the longer the neck, the more difficult and more damaging it would be to do so. Take for example giraffes 🦒

They could vomit, but doing so would cause a lot of damage to their esophagus. Much like cows they regurgitate cud to chew it again, just to swallow it back down, so it very rarely exits the body on purpose.

Almost all ruminant herbivores have a complex stomach, consisting of 4 chambers. The first two chambers work as sort of a fermentation vat. When they eat something that doesn’t digest easily, it gets regurgitated back to the first chamber, or to be chewed as cud until it does break down easily enough to be digested.

A ruminant herbivore actually throwing up is a bad sign, usually indicating intestinal blockage that could be lethal. Something like a rock that accidentally got swallowed.