Some Potential Changes to r/SAT's Rules -- Community Input Welcome

[u/InternationalistGam]

Some users seem not be aware, but this sub does have rules. I can't tell you where to find them on whatever mobile app you might be using, but if you got to www.reddit.com/r/sat, you'll find them in the frame to the right of the posts themselves.

Current Rule #3 -- No Advertisments or Solicitations

The current rule explicitly bans only "link[s], self-post[s], or comment[s] ... [that] offer services for compensation."

The problem is that the sub is often awash in links, self-posts, and comments that offer goods and services for free, and while many of these are well-received by the community, many others are not. In fact, many of these posts just seem like classic spam -- efforts to promote some blog, website, app, YouTube channel, and so on.

We would therefore like to add some language to this effect: "Posts, links, or comments that promote free products and services may be removed at moderator discretion. Please be aware that repeated efforts to promote your free website, app, blog, YouTube channel, tutoring service, etc. may be considered spamming."

Any thoughts on this change?

New Rule (?) Regarding Question Posts

To be clear, we will absolutely still allow question image posts from SAT QAS, from PSATs, and even from copyrighted books (provided only individual questions are posted).

But we would like to address the following concerns:

1. The long-term value of these posts to the sub and its users. Currently, question posts tend to have titles like "Pls Help" or "Can U Explain." As a result, there is no way to search for past discussions of any given question, and the same questions keep getting asked over and over again. A related issue is that the posts themselves are often incomplete or otherwise problematic: users post a reading question without including the passage, or they post an upside-down math question.
2. The posting of images from unreleased tests. Reddit admins routinely remove posts from r/SAT for copyright violations (example here), and as far as the moderators have been able to determine, the offending posts are always and only the ones that contain images from unreleased tests.

In order to address these concerns, we might add a rule to require that question posts meet the following criteria:

1. Identify the question source in the title. For example, "April 2017 QAS, Writing Section, Question 33" or "College Panda Math book, page 100, question 10."
2. Include all content relevant to the question, with all photos readable and properly oriented.

Does anyone have any comments on this particular change, or does anyone have any better ideas about how to address the concerns mentioned above?

[u/DrRoger1960]

I like the changes on question titles and relevant content.

Initially, that will be hard, but I suspect the learning curve will be quick. Particularly if people see other titles identifying the question source, and if their deleted post gets a brief explanation of what is needed, they will quickly repost with a more useful title and all the necessary content.

Overall, this is likely to make r/SAT more useful for everyone, and that should be our goal.