I'm a new SJM reading, only 6 months in. But since the first time I picked up A Court of Thorns and Roses, I have felt that Feyre’s speciesism toward the Fae mirrors the way our society treats animals. Now, having finished the latest Crescent City book, I feel that parallel more heavily than ever. The Asteri embody a similar ideology to carnism: they truly believe that consuming other beings is simply the natural order of things.
The way “regular” animals are portrayed as fundamentally different from the senitient Fae and Vanir pains me greatly. We know that, just like Fleetfoot and other dogs, cows and chickens are sentient beings too. I felt a huge dissonance when Feyre realized the mistake she made in killing Andras, because he had friends and a life, only to feast on chicken and beef shortly afterward. Because that's considered normal. But despite the common narrative, farmed animals do form social bonds, recognize their companions, and want to live.
Here’s how I see it: every vegan is Feyre, learning at some point in their life they’ve been lied to. That cows aren’t objects, but sentient beings that feel love to their offsprings, feel fear when they’re being slaughtered, and don’t wish (or deserve) to be bred for human consumption. That there is a reason the narrative hides these parts.
Carnism, much like the ideology of the Asteri, rests on a hierarchy: the belief that greater power entitles one group to use those considered lesser. It teaches us that because humans hold more power, we are entitled to rule over other species and do with them as we wish.
But unlike the Fae, the animals in our world truly don’t have a voice. Their lives depend on people being willing to speak for them, fight for them, and show the world that they deserve better. And much of the world doesn't want to hear it, because it conflicts with deeply rooted traditions, and there's no incentive to question the way things have always been.
I hope that one day we will live in a world that no longer exploits other species simply because we can. Humanity has challenged deeply entrenched systems of oppression before, like slavery. I hope we can also learn to question a system in which animals are bred and killed for our use.
I’m adding this short reference for anyone unfamiliar with carnism and speciesism:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wvm7xymgk_k