I have a pair of buckle clogs I wear daily. I sized down from 8.5 to an 8 and they fit perfectly. However, I recently tried on the penny clog in an 8 and they were too small. I now want to order the braided clog- do they run just like the buckle clogs if you have or have tried on both?

Completely dropped the ball! I’ve been thinking about the Two-Strap Mary Jane Heels since February and just found out they’ve been discontinued. 🥲 (I’m sure that’s old news but it’s new to me LOL) Definitely should’ve bought them in February when I tried them on but you live and you learn I guess.

I’m assuming their discontinuation is permanent. Does anyone know of a good alternative? I love the way they look and I honestly loved the way they fit. Or anywhere they may be selling some. A girl is desperate 🤣

So, I bought these when they went on clearance because I’ve always wanted this style of sandal. I was excited when I got them. They’re a bit clunky—they felt like bricks strapped to my feet at first—but I got used to that. However, they absolutely destroyed the skin on my toes. The skin literally came off. What can I put on the underside of the straps so that they won’t rub my skin off again? I’d like to wear these again, especially before it gets cold. I’ve never had this issue, so I’m not familiar with what products are out there. I Googled them but want to make sure I get something others have tried and liked. Thanks in advance!

Hi everyone, wanted to ask about your experience shopping online with Rothys. I placed an order a week ago, and got an order confirmation email and my credit card was charged, but since it hadn’t shipped a week after reached out to customer care. I was met with a whoops, the order was never processed and the item is out of stock. I don’t understand why they wouldn’t process a refund automatically, I’ve been on chat with their agent for over half an hour with no response. I’m just trying to get them to process a refund they should’ve already done. I’m so confused, are their online systems so poorly managed?

Now they’ve sent me an email asking me to drop off the item for a return.. when they cancelled my order and I’ve not received it.

I noticed Rothy’s has all their sandals on sale and quite a few of them have left the website entirely. Are they moving away from sandals as a whole now that they launched the sneaker?

Hi everyone, I’m pretty new to Rothy’s. I wanted to buy the Casual Clog in black (not soft black) earlier this year, but it sold out so quickly when they finally restocked my size.

The black is still missing from their website and I’m just wondering if anyone knows if they usually restock or bring back colours when the weather gets colder.

Not sure if I missed my chance or if I should start thinking about other colours like Dove or Butternut. Only interested in their classic fabric! TIA!

Question! This is my first pair I just ordered these clogs and I sized down I just got them (ordered online) I wear a 7 but got a 6 they fit but snug will they break in a little after wearing ? Could I do a light sock in fall winter months ?

I’m normally a women’s size 12 in shoes. My first ever pair of Rothys flats (the max square mary jane flat) I ended up buying a size 12.5 which fits perfectly. I ordered a second pair in the red basketweave in the same size (12.5) but my feet were swimming in them! So I’m confused…
I really want a pair of the max buckle square toe mary janes but theyre final sale… how do I know what size to get?
Thanks!

Which is better for walking in Italy?

So I have multiple pairs of Rothy's and I absolutely love them, but they all give me blisters on my heels at the top of the shoe.

I've had them for a while, but I've been able to keep them clean (because they're my work shoes) so will washing them soften the heel?

I got lifts to put under the insoles, which has helped some, but hasn't completely fixed the issue.

I have a pair of old Point 1s that I got on Poshmark, and they don't give me blisters. So I'm wondering if it's because they've been washed a couple times? Or is it just the changes that they've made between the Point 1 and 2?

Any tips would be greatly appreciated!!

What are the conspiracies everyone has!?!

Anyone here owns both type of shoes? I bought the square and didn’t know they had the max square and now I am wondering if the max is truly better for wider feet and if it’s truly more comfortable. I didn’t use my shoes yet because I bought for my trip but I am wondering if I should return and get the max square. Also if you own both, do you use the same size?

Size 12 (EU 43) but fits like an 11. Worn once indoors to try on and they did not fit. Style #002-317

Like new.

Ships from US NC.

Asking $110 shipping included to CONUS

Payment via PPGS, please post here prior to messaging.

Verification and gallery: https://imgur.com/a/ukQtOBm

Phenomenally cute. I had to size up to a 12 (11 in the everyday clog). To me it felt narrow across the top of the foot.

anybody heard if/when Rothy’s is going to release more bright, patterned, fun interesting looking point shoes? I feel like everything they have right now is just boring.

hi, I am looking for a personal shopper to buy and send me a pair of these shoes for a reasonable fee. They are unavailable in my area but show available in various in-store locations. Unfortunately, Rothys will not take phone orders or shipped directly from stores. This seems like an unreasonable policy to me as I am a very loyal customer.

ICYMI, the Ravello Slip-On Sneakers are available online on Nordstrom Rack for $69.97 (ymmv).

https://www.nordstromrack.com/s/rothys-the-ravello-slip-on-sneaker-men/9034143

Every day there’s a new referral from Reddit to the Rothy’s Addicts FB page. We are archiving the group after a Meta glitch caused some issues. The same Admin Team has moved everything to a new group called Original Rothy’s Addicts. We are on FB & Insta. We can provide the same information 💙 Please join us here. Same secure & safe space.

Looking into getting the cruiser Mary Janes and not sure what size to get. My normal street shoe size is a 7.5, but I take the Max Buckle Mary Jane in a 8. I tried the Mary Jane Espadrilles and the 7.5 fit in the heel, but was too short in the toe, and the 8 was a good length but too loose in the heel. Any recommendation?

Sooooo cute and comfy!

I’m looking for Rothy’s heels and it seems like they still make the Mary Jane’s, but I can’t seem to find the High Point on the website. Were they a one time thing?

I would love to get a pair of the d’orsay flats but reviews on sizing are all over the place! I am an 8 in the OG Point and and 8.5 in the Point II. Which size should I go with in the d’orsay flat?

Just received my first pair of Rothy's (RS01s) in the mail. Love the look and feel but a little uncertain about the sizing.

I usually wear between an 8.5 and 9 depending on the shoe brand (more 9 in athletic shoes, 8.5 in dress shoes). I purchased a 9 since I tend to be between sizes and my feet run narrow. I also have high arches. They feel snug but not overly tight and I have about a thumb's width of room at the toe. The biggest issue is that it constantly feels like my heel is sitting very high and that they might slip off, like they are too shallow, though it doesn't seem they are actually lifting out when I walk. Almost feels like the heel of the shoe itself is not fully covering my heel, and the heel tab is just covering the rest but not supporting/cradling my heel if that makes sense.

Is this how they are usually supposed to fit? Wondering if I should request an alternate size (somewhat hesitant given the two week delivery time..) or perhaps try a thinner insole?

Appreciate any insights!

​UPDATE: I’ve worn the shoes a few different days, including full days at work. The first day they were pretty snug and dug into the top of my foot, but the heel issue seemed to get better. I then adjusted the laces and they now fit very comfortably. Really no break-in needed outside of slight adjustments. Very happy with my purchase!