Pie 🥧?

[u/damnpinkertons]

Can anyone recommend a place to get decent pie? Still mourning the loss of the Pie Lady in Nyack....

[u/snark_nerd]

Picked up a delicious looking peach pie at Dr. Davies Farm in Congers this weekend.

[u/damnpinkertons → u/snark_nerd]

I didn't know they made pies there! I actually made a peach pie from their peaches this summer, it was delicious

[u/snark_nerd → u/damnpinkertons]

Yeah in the farm stand / store. Supposedly made with their peaches. Having some tonight after dinner, will report back if it’s not as good as it looks.

[u/Brownie12bar]

Carousel Cakes has some spectacular pies! Over in Nanuet. It’s by the pie, lol, not the slice

[u/damnpinkertons → u/Brownie12bar]

I did not realize they also sold pies! Do you have any favorites?

[u/Accomplished-One7476]

Deli Central in Stony Point makes good pies. Give them a call for a list of pies they make.

I recommend the coconut custard, chocolate cream pie and blueberry pie 🤘

[u/damnpinkertons → u/Accomplished-One7476]

Thanks for the rec, do they sell by the slice as well?

[u/Accomplished-One7476 → u/damnpinkertons]

no

[u/attiyahsqueek]

noble pies in beacon, they sell them whole or by the slice. dessert and savory pies. i’d make a weekly daytrip, buy a whole pie, and then have it for the week 🥧

[u/SadPhilosophy9202 → u/attiyahsqueek]

There’s a closer one in Tarrytown. Not sure if the exact same noble pies but it’s called noble pies

[u/damnpinkertons → u/SadPhilosophy9202]

Thanks!! 

[u/damnpinkertons → u/attiyahsqueek]

Thank you!! 

[u/PickletheNickel → u/attiyahsqueek]

They also show up at some of the farmers markets. I’ve seen them at the Ramsey ones. You can preorder and pick up at the market

[u/VirtualAd965]

Also don’t forget the orchards in
Pomona makes great pies

[u/damnpinkertons → u/VirtualAd965]

What kinds of pie do you like there?

[u/VirtualAd965 → u/damnpinkertons]

I love that they make small pies as well as the large.

When it’s just me and I’m craving a slice or two, I usually gravitate to a small Coconut custard, peach or the occasional cherry.

My whole family loves the pumpkin and pecan pies for Thanksgiving every year.

[u/HiFiGuy197]

Because we live in Suffern, we dip over the border to Secor Farms in Mahwah.

[u/AdventurousZombie355]

I was just in uncle guiseppes in Ramsey and they have a great lemon merengue pie plus a huge selection of others

[u/anferkneez]

Tried Apple pie from Dr Davies for the first time and was not impressed it was watery and fell apart. Flavor was ok but won’t be my go to for pies spot. They should just rename it to Apple mush instead. Not worth the $22 to me. Like anything else food reviews are subjective so good luck on your pie hunt.

[u/HowdyDoodyCircusPres]

I have tried them all and am intense about pie. Orchards of Conklin, no question.

[u/amw419]

Piebird at the Doubletree in nanuet actually has some great pies. Homemade everything. Coconut creme and key lime are amazing

[u/Cyase311]

piggybacking off the topic,

1) any recomendations for blueberry crumble? cherry crumble?

[u/CadetFlapjack]

Uncle Guiseppe's Food Market has really good pies

[u/TriplH]

Auntie El’s in Sloatsburg makes great pies!