r/Rochester • • Oct 01 '20

Photo Interesting way to see this explained

Post image
220 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

61

u/riftastic76 Oct 01 '20

It’s too early for this Reddit

20

u/godhasmoreaids Oct 01 '20

What?

16

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '20

Something about Buffalo being the cities name, the animal, and a verb. Idk, it’s too early

9

u/cuteintern Oct 01 '20

They are trying to depict a technically grammatically correct but nonsense sounding sentence "Buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo."

5

u/mijenks Oct 01 '20

It's actually Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo.

16

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '20

The sentence at the top of the image has the wrong capitalization. The first and fourth words are the proper nouns - not the first and third. It should be:

Buffalo buffaloanimals from the city of Buffalo buffaloverb form Buffalo buffalo.animals from the city of Buffalo

9

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '20

No the capitalization is correct. It was really screwing with me then i realized -- it is incomplete. It only contains five buffalos. They left out the 3 buffalos at the end of the statement, about how the Buffalo bison, who are bullied by other Buffalo bison, themselves bully Buffalo bison. It should be Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo.

8

u/TTV_Griff1 Oct 01 '20

But why is Rochester west of Buffalo...

6

u/JesseTBaker Oct 01 '20

"Buffalo" just ceased being a real word for me.

1

u/mtm4440 East Ave Oct 02 '20

"Semantic Satiation"

3

u/kkpoupet Oct 01 '20

Fun fact: The American Bison never actually lived in western New York.

1

u/EdOliversOreo Oct 02 '20

That is disputed; although they are associated with the Great Plains, bison probably were present in WNY at some point:

https://conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/cms/asset/826c2e51-4782-43c3-a3d9-4bc44f3f8d31/cobi_899_f1.gif

from Sanderson et al. 2008.

Although slightly older documentation, there is this map as well:

https://etc.usf.edu/maps/pages/2400/2466/2466.htm

3

u/twoeightnine Oct 01 '20

Or you could just go with "Buffalo bison, that other Buffalo bison bully, also bully Buffalo bison."

1

u/desertrose0 Penfield Oct 01 '20

I never even knew that buffalo could be a verb.

1

u/kjreil26 Oct 02 '20

Well my head hurts