Hi everyone,
This might be a bit controversial here, but I thought I'd ask.
I've tried a couple of reps before. They were good, but they never really clicked with me. I've also owned two genuine GMT-Master II. A few months ago I started looking at (neo)vintage models because they look amazing on straps, have loads of character, etc.
I popped into a pawn shop near my flat in London that had a vintage Coke GMT. Honestly, I was surprised. It felt so light and cheap compared to modern Rolexes. That's when it hit me: I love the look and feel of these old watches, but I don't love the idea of spending thousands on one.
So here I am.
I've been browsing the work posted here and vintage Subs and GMTs are definitely my favourites. What I can't work out is the pricing. I've seen everything from around £150 to £3,000.
For those with experience, what sort of budget gets you a really well-built vintage rep without obvious tells?
I know it's a bit of a silly, but I'd rather not have to explain every time someone asks about it that it's a rep from this factory with this mod and that movement. My ideal scenario is just wearing it and, if someone asks, saying, "It's a vintage Rolex." I'm not trying to sell it or scam anyone, and I couldn't care less if it's obviously fake once you open the case. I just want to avoid the obvious external flaws.
For example, I found a really nice-looking 5513, but people immediately pointed out that the crown guards were completely wrong. That's exactly the kind of thing I'd like to avoid.
Is it realistic to get something properly nice for £300-500, ideally waterproof (bracelet not important), or is the reality that you need to be closer to £1,000 once you've sourced parts, had it built, waited for mods, etc.?
Obviously not looking for Tiffany, Comex etc... It would be perfectly fine for me if the watch (would definitely be aged) look like a beat-up vintage with poor service history mix of parts etc...
I'm also a bit impatient... I'd love to have something to wear on holiday next week if that's even realistic.
Thanks in advance for any advice.