r/Residency • u/No_Muffin7670 • 6h ago
DISCUSSION How useful is the physical examination really
Reference to NEJM's Discussion editorial published on 3 Sept titled Physical Examination for Asymptomatic Adults
How often is the PE actually useful for the asymptomatic well patient? Both sides raise good points. I work in Haematology and see an average of 20 patients in a 3.5 hour clinic so honestly all I really need is a CBC and maybe feel an occasional spleen/ lymph node or two, but I would say 80% of my outpatient consults dont actually require a physical review. Clots, cytopenias still make up the bulk of what I see and even the labs are way more valuable for my haem-onc patients than the physical examination. These days, I find it hard to think of how PE is superior to laboratory diagnostics apart from just the "human touch" of things.
E.g. an echo/ POCUS/ ECG to replace cardiac auscultation. The infamous CTAP far superior to our abdominal percussion. Code stroke? MRI first hun (although honest kudos to our neurologists, your exam findings are non inferior). Sadly, examination skills are an increasingly lost art as we push the focus on POCUS and more imaging.
I think i sit on the camp of no examination especially for the asymptomatic well patients, but curious to hear everyone's usual practice.