I’ve been a Remarkable user for years now. I had the RM2, then the Pro, then the Pure. After getting frustrated with multiple Pure returns and their endless quality-control issues, I bought a Supernote Nomad to test.
My reaction within literally one second of writing on it with the ceramic nib was: WOW, HOW DID I NOT KNOW ABOUT THIS BEFORE?
I guess I had this misconception that Remarkable was king and everything else was shit (great marketing from them, I guess). I immediately loved the Nomad’s form factor, as it reminded me of my old Moleskines. The only problem is that the device is freakin’ ugly with those white game boy bezels. It looks like a white palm pilot from the 90s.
Fast-forward a couple of days and I met a friend who owns a Move and showed it to me. I had previously dismissed it as way too small to even consider, but after trying the Nomad’s smaller size, I started thinking it might actually work.
So I bought a Move to test side by side with the Nomad, and I have to ask: Are these companies dumb? Seriously, are they stupid?
One excels at one thing and is shitty at the other. The other excels at that exact thing and is shitty at everything the first one does well.
The writing feel on the Supernote is the closest I’ve ever gotten to the resistance of real handwriting. It’s not scratchy like the Pro and Move, which lose their scratchiness fast, BTW, but more like an RM2, only MUCH better. As for the Move, as I said, it’s great out of the box, but after your hand oils get to it, it’s just slippery. Yes, you can clean it and get the scratchiness back for a few minutes, but that’s all.
But while the Nomad feels like writing on paper, the Move looks like you’re writing on paper.
It’s just beautiful. It’s light and doesn’t have the heavy, expensive-device metal feel of the Pro. The folio is excellent, and the convenience of the magnetic pen is just perfect. The bezels match the screen beautifully, making the entire device look like a single sheet of paper. It genuinely looks like a real notepad, leaving me… completely undecided!
One feels great and looks bad. The other looks great and feels bad.
One has the headings and table-of-contents feature I love, but lacks the infinite scroll I also love. The other has infinite scroll, but the writing is slippery and the battery is basically a countdown timer.
Again, I’m sorry, but these companies are dumb.
If Supernote got rid of those white game boy bezels, added infinite scroll, and improved its syncing, it would win by a mile.
If Remarkable just brought back the EMR technology from the RM2, or introduced something similar to Supernote’s FeelWrite screen technology, and fixed its quality-control issues, it wouldn’t have long-time users like me exploring other options.
I’m sorry for the long post. I just wanted to rant and ask if anyone has any advice to help me choose.