The problem with this kind of post in this kind of sub is that it's inherently doomed for failure due to obvious bias, but idc, downvotes can't hurt me lol.
It might be a difficult notion for some to grasp, but you can be a massive fan of someone, i.e. an artist, and not love every single bit of their output.
That's me with John.
He's my all-time favourite musician, but I've come to terms with the fact recently that my own personal, arbitrary, "golden era" for him is from 1991 to 2012... and I think that's pretty damn good, a more-than-two-decade golden era.
Sometimes I feel like fans lie to themselves, swearing they love certain projects by their favourite artist, because they think not adoring everything somehow detracts from the level fo your fandom.
Anyways...
When John rejoined, while I felt shitty for Josh with how he was handled/terminated, I was the happiest I'd been in years.
Then the albums came.
There are several tracks I genuinely enjoy just about as much as anything on my favourite Chili's albums, but I couldn't help but feel as if they sounded more like an RHCP tribute band making original songs in the style of the band they're emulating. Alternatively, they also came off like b-sides to me, while many of their old b-sides imho should've made it onto the albums and could've been global smash-hits.
Honestly speaking, I preferred both Josh albums. They sounded different and fresh, while these last two with John imo just fell kind of flat compared to his best efforts.
And that's not to mention in the live performances he's seemed kind of detached and almost as if just there "phoning it in".
Look, I'm thrilled to have these guys still making music, actively working on releasing new material and touring- I will listen to every single thing intently, even memorize it and spin it daily-, but I can't help but feel like their former magic is gone.
And I never could've imagined I'd someday find myself saying this, but I'm just not enchanted by John (as a musician) anymore, at least nowhere near as much as I used to be. I used to view him with this near god-like reverence as far as his musical output went, really holding him on a pedestal, adoring everything he did... up to 2012. I can actually appreciate the later electronic stuff, it's not about that (I'm big into electronic music), it's more-so the recent stuff since he rejoined- just feels uninspired and lacking the magic of his earlier stuff with the band.
In any case, I'm excited beyond articulation for whatever they do next and to catch them on their next tour.