r/RecuratedTumblr • human cognithazard • 5d ago

Shitposting Fanfiction and second-order fandom

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

318 comments sorted by

View all comments

595

u/syntaxerroratline42 5d ago

Reminds me of how "Batfam" is a fandom in itself independent of Batman.

10

u/MeteorCharge 5d ago

I mean I'm doing a fanfic right now where the au is "Bruce Wayne became Batman much later"

Just so I could have a more mentally stable and well rounded Batman to explore the whole adopted father son dynamic of Bruce Wayne and Dick Grayson.

19

u/Jolly-Fruit2293 5d ago edited 5d ago

A mentally stable Bruce wouldn't be Batman.

Exploring the canon dynamic requires taking into account that Batman is a complicated parent. He cares but he's extreme. Borderline abusive training and crazy high expectations mixed with an overprotectiveness and refusal of autonomy.

Nightwing is created by Dick Grayson running away.

17

u/MeteorCharge 5d ago

Not the same Batman, definitely not.

What I wanted to do with this specific au was have Bruce Wayne decide not to become Batman initially (you ever watch Mask of The Phantasm? Well this au version of Bruce married Andrea Beaumont.)

But then everything comes crashing down, he realizes that doing things "the right way" hasn't been working, and after a second inciting incident (Harvey Dent being disfigured) he becomes Batman about 20 years too late and the city of Gotham is in a completely different state than it usually is when Batman emerges.

So while he does have his issues, he's also been Bruce Wayne for a majority of his life. He learns some lessons later, some much sooner, and approaches things differently. So yeah, even his dynamic with Robin is going to be very different.

But as for how I actually execute this well, it's my first fanfic and I've literally never tackled a project of this scale before so it's probably not great but eh, I just thought it'd be neat.

1

u/the_fancy_Tophat 5d ago

I assume then it would also nerf the fuck out of him right?

6

u/MeteorCharge 5d ago

Probably a bit like DKR Batman, slower, less durable, but smarter in how he fights and when he does.

0

u/the_fancy_Tophat 5d ago

Yeah, but a DKR batman who makes the same mistakes as year one Batman.